cRPG

cRPG => Beginner's Help and Guides => Topic started by: Fazar on March 28, 2012, 08:07:14 am

Title: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 28, 2012, 08:07:14 am
It could just be Im against people with 200 two handed skills, but using the fastest one hander I can, and about 109 points into one handed mastery, I get outswung by people with claymores, and polearms.  There has to be something Im doing wrong.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on March 28, 2012, 08:09:43 am
Yes, you need to work on your footwork and turning into the swing. 110 wpf is way enough to not get spammed, hell even 1 wpf is.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: larlek on March 28, 2012, 08:10:46 am
109 isn't "fast" it's acceptable but really you're going to be slow untill you get at least 130-140 in your weapon spec. Most agi builds have like 170+ in their weapon.

Yes, you need to work on your footwork and turning into the swing. 110 wpf is way enough to not get spammed, hell even 1 wpf is.

+1
your footwork is what matters. I've been killed by retired peasants with wooden swords. not because of their lvl or stats but because of their skill.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on March 28, 2012, 09:43:30 am
109 isn't "fast" it's acceptable but really you're going to be slow untill you get at least 130-140 in your weapon spec. Most agi builds have like 170+ in their weapon.

+1
your footwork is what matters. I've been killed by retired peasants with wooden swords. not because of their lvl or stats but because of their skill.

Another reason you're being outswung by slower weapons is turning. Not just your positioning relative to your enemy is important, but you can also turn into your swing to make it connect faster. Just turn into the direction you're swinging in to do it.
Go to the duelserver and watch good duelers. You'll be able to figure out the movement patterns quickly.

Wpf only becomes an issue imo, when you have 2 good duelers. Only then the marginal speed increase might make a difference.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: larlek on March 28, 2012, 10:11:28 am
It's mean to put lines through peoples comments

My feelings have been hurt
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on March 28, 2012, 12:04:20 pm
It's mean to put lines through peoples comments

My feelings have been hurt

I'm sorry. I won't do it again.

Here, have a cookie:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: larlek on March 28, 2012, 12:07:09 pm
Good. I shall accept your cookie and we will speak no more of this.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Mlekce on March 28, 2012, 01:13:45 pm
dude it is because they have longer reach. yoo cant realy do anything about it, except develop agility and athletic,grap steel pick,big shield and get close to their face and kill the bastards. Beware of axes,and maulers,and kicks.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: [ptx] on March 28, 2012, 01:20:22 pm
dude it is because they have longer reach. yoo cant realy do anything about it, except develop agility and athletic,grap steel pick,big shield and get close to their face and kill the bastards. Beware of axes,and maulers,and kicks.

Yeah, that makes a ton of sense.

Alternatively, learn footwork, timing and use a long one handed sword.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on March 28, 2012, 01:29:58 pm
As I understood it, the OP meant others are swinging their slower weapons faster than he is, eventhough he has a fast 1h weapon.

I don't really see the relevance of reach, as it has very little to do with swing speed (other than that longer weapons are usually slower).
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Zanze on March 28, 2012, 02:50:46 pm
If getting outswung while using a 1h, only a few probs. You aren't turning into your swung, you are using the wrong swing(right swing at close range), or you are simply reacting too slow. Practice
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Camaris on March 28, 2012, 03:01:15 pm
You can spam some people even with mauls if they are doing it the wrong way ;)
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 28, 2012, 04:16:54 pm
I could see the turning while swinging thing.  Also would ping/shields contribute to the slowness?  Say the delay in lowering the shield, then the delay in swinging the weapon?
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on March 28, 2012, 04:26:14 pm
I could see the turning while swinging thing.  Also would ping/shields contribute to the slowness?  Say the delay in lowering the shield, then the delay in swinging the weapon?

Ping contributes to slowness yes. So does a slow shield.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on March 28, 2012, 04:39:29 pm
besides FOOTWORK which is very important, also note that the different swings have different speeds & reaches.

with 1h

Left to right is shortest reach but fastest.
Right to left swing is longest reach but slowest. 

DO NOT use right swing in close combat until you get more experience in the game, its a death sentence for newer players.  I would also avoid thrusts too as a new player, it takes time to figure out when and HOW exactly to use them.

Left swings should account for 50% or more of your attacks a shielder.  Circle your enemies COUNTER-clockwise for maximum effect.


16 generation shielder here.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: martyrAD on March 28, 2012, 06:42:59 pm
get a knightly heater and a scimitar, go to town. you cant accidently trust, and its got good speed and reach.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on March 28, 2012, 06:56:19 pm
Ping contributes to slowness yes. So does a slow shield.

I was also under the impression that shield speed affects how fast your weapon swings when you are using the shield.  I was told however that shield speed only affects how fast your shield blocks. 
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vodner on March 28, 2012, 07:19:44 pm
Footwork will stop you from getting out-swung. I only have 113 WPF at the moment, and I only get double-swung when I make a mistake.

Stick to overheads and left swings at close range. Thrusts are also good, but there is a learning curve involved in preventing them from glancing.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Teeth on March 28, 2012, 08:22:21 pm
Use the almighty leftswing spam.

What is your ping btw?

Oh, and also be sure to attack right after you blocked, some people are a bit slow on that and then get sad because they get outspammed.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on March 28, 2012, 08:39:28 pm
I was also under the impression that shield speed affects how fast your weapon swings when you are using the shield.  I was told however that shield speed only affects how fast your shield blocks.

It doesn't affect swing speed. It just "contributes" to getting spammed, because you don't get your block up that fast.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vexus on March 28, 2012, 09:23:36 pm
get a knightly heater and a scimitar, go to town. you cant accidently trust, and its got good speed and reach.

[Off Topic]

What movie/whataver is your sig from?

[On Topic]

You can train turning swings in single player or in duel server, you will better understand a new method of fighting where you have some chance to survive rather than having to wait for the perfect moment online at first.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on March 28, 2012, 09:34:32 pm
[Off Topic]

What movie/whataver is your sig from?

[On Topic]

You can train turning swings in single player or in duel server, you will better understand a new method of fighting where you have some chance to survive rather than having to wait for the perfect moment online at first.

Google his quote in the sig and maybe add "movie quotes".

Doing that gave me this result:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1240982/
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: zagibu on March 28, 2012, 09:54:33 pm
109 WPF isn't a lot. If you wear fat armor, it will be reduced to 90 or less.

I think what you are experiencing is hiltslashes. Unfortunately, it's currently possible to do damage VERY early in the animation, when it actually should glance on anything but naked skin, but since Paul changed the armor formula, it's even possible to cut through plate this way. 2h animations are best for this, but even polearm and 1h left to right swing works, if you use a weapon with high damage and have high PS.

That's why I suggest you never try the right to left swing against 2h in tight situations. They will connect earlier, even if you blocked their previous swing and start your counterswing immediately afterwards.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Teeth on March 28, 2012, 11:28:52 pm
That's why I suggest you never try the right to left swing against 2h in tight situations. They will connect earlier, even if you blocked their previous swing and start your counterswing immediately afterwards.
Hiltslashes are not used that much, atleast at this side of the ocean. I would suggest always using the leftswing in any tight situation. It connects really fast and only a perfectly executed hiltslash will hit quicker, they are quite rare. You can actually do a double left swing a lot when using proper mouse movement, not enabling your opponent to attack back.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 28, 2012, 11:32:05 pm
I haven't had a chance to try it yet(the left swing that is, didn't know it was quicker).  I wear rather light armour minus helmet, and gloves.  My shield is one of the quickets I could grab, I have 6 into shields, and use the Nordic Shortsword.

My ping ranges from 90-100 usually.

-edit-

I also just want to thank everyone who has contributed so far to this.  I'm actually not used to a community as friendly or helpful as this.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vodner on March 29, 2012, 02:28:26 am
I haven't had a chance to try it yet(the left swing that is, didn't know it was quicker).  I wear rather light armour minus helmet, and gloves.  My shield is one of the quickets I could grab, I have 6 into shields, and use the Nordic Shortsword.

My ping ranges from 90-100 usually.

-edit-

I also just want to thank everyone who has contributed so far to this.  I'm actually not used to a community as friendly or helpful as this.
An elite scimitar would be a better choice than a short sword. The extra reach and cut damage more than make up for the lower speed. The Nordic champion sword, knightly arming sword, and Italian sword would also be worth looking into.

100 ping isn't unplayable, but it is a substantial disadvantage. You're will have less time to counter-attack after hearing the weapon block sound, compared to most of your opponents. Player positions will also be somewhat out of sync.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 29, 2012, 02:39:03 am
What about an Arabian Straight Sword?  Those are the two I have currently.  One for reach, the other for speed.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Logen on March 29, 2012, 02:49:35 am
but since Paul changed the armor formula
Been doing it all the way from native to present day.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: rustyspoon on March 29, 2012, 02:52:24 am
What about an Arabian Straight Sword?  Those are the two I have currently.  One for reach, the other for speed.

Instead of two swords you're better off using a sword and some type of specialist weapon, like an axe for shield breaking or a hammer for heavy armor.

Personally I use 3 weapons, an Italian Sword, a Military Hammer and a Broad 1-handed Axe.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Gurnisson on March 29, 2012, 02:57:08 am
Elite Scimitar is a great weapon for starting as a one-hander.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: isatis on March 29, 2012, 03:06:18 am
don't start with scimi

starts with simple sword

why? just to handle the stab a bit.
and because if you get used to that scimi you will be a speed whore!
simple sword is the best beginners choice!
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on March 29, 2012, 07:06:41 am
don't start with scimi

starts with simple sword

why? just to handle the stab a bit.
and because if you get used to that scimi you will be a speed whore!
simple sword is the best beginners choice!

nope, disagree. should gradually work in tactics.  having a 4 direction sword just compounds learning curve, not to mention simple sword is an exercise in futility, noob wont be able to even hurt plated enemies.  Scimi's are good learning swords.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 29, 2012, 08:50:37 am
Tried it out, still getting smoked by two handers, and pole arm users.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on March 29, 2012, 08:53:09 am
Tried it out, still getting smoked by two handers, and pole arm users.

Practice, young one. You can't expect to become good in a day.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 29, 2012, 08:58:22 am
Practice, young one. You can't expect to become good in a day.

I know Im kind of judging this before getting 'good' at it, but Im really feeling at the brute end of the stick for this.  I've roughed it out through peasant up to level 22 now, and I wouldn't call myself a shabby gamer, but too often it feels like Im just cannon fodder.  Only really good for standing at a flag in Siege.

Oddly my less savy friend who plays this seems to be doing better than me.  I don't want to say it's because he's using a two hander, and Im using one hander, but I out perform him in any other game that requires more twitch based skill.

It's very frustrating, and Im trying to learn, but it's feeling far more work than worth right now.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: HarunYahya on March 29, 2012, 09:11:05 am
Well i was a 2 hander for long time and before that i was a polearm guy for a long time again .
I just started my 1 hander career a week ago :) so far some things i can tell :
-When i was a 2 hander or polearm i used to spam shielders and circle them till i get to their behind here is what happens :
If they use a heavy shield they go retarded and block till their shield breaks , when it breaks they panic and spam the shit out of you .
As a heavy armour str based (24-18 ^^) 2hander i didn't give a fuck about 1hander hits since they glance or deal shitty damage (Except blunt-pierce type i spam more careful rather than a crazy berserker if i see a guy with warhammer or steelpick :D )so i didn't even bother to block and continue my spam .

Now as a shielder i experience the same occasion but i am on the other side of the situation :D
People don't care about my swings , they dont even block while i swing  :lol: i use a plate covered round shield cuz it looks so fucking awesome
I found 2 solutions to survive "careless 2h spam"
1)Use a fast shield and get min 7 power strike
2)IFight without shield on 1v1 occasions

I dislike fast shields cuz of their looks so i chose the 2nd option :)
I only use my shield on crowded fights(As a shielder you can get the attention of most of the enemies and while they try to spam you , your teammates can get easy kills so it is effective to "tank" enemies on crowded fights rather than trying to get some kills in my opinion.) and chasing archers now and i am happy with it.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on March 29, 2012, 09:13:46 am
I know Im kind of judging this before getting 'good' at it, but Im really feeling at the brute end of the stick for this.  I've roughed it out through peasant up to level 22 now, and I wouldn't call myself a shabby gamer, but too often it feels like Im just cannon fodder.  Only really good for standing at a flag in Siege.

Oddly my less savy friend who plays this seems to be doing better than me.  I don't want to say it's because he's using a two hander, and Im using one hander, but I out perform him in any other game that requires more twitch based skill.

It's very frustrating, and Im trying to learn, but it's feeling far more work than worth right now.

Few things.

Everyone except very good players will get roughed at level 22, it's because most of the players are level 30, 31 or even more, so there's quite a big stat difference. Technically, you really are cannon fodder till you hit atleast 27.

About your friend, define "doing better"? It's normal that he's getting more kills with a two hander, two handers have much higher damage than one handers and because of this you get more killing blows.

It was frustrating to all of us at first, this game takes a while to get a hang of. Most of us started with Native where you already have a "max level" char and are on equal playing ground (except the player skill). Also, the average cRPG player is better than the average Native, so I can imagine it must be quite frustrating to come here and get your ass handed to you 24/7.

Stick with it, practice and you'll eventually become good, how much time depending on your talent.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Corwin on March 29, 2012, 09:28:12 am
Few things.

Everyone except very good players will get roughed at level 22, it's because most of the players are level 30, 31 or even more, so there's quite a big stat difference. Technically, you really are cannon fodder till you hit atleast 27.

About your friend, define "doing better"? It's normal that he's getting more kills with a two hander, two handers have much higher damage than one handers and because of this you get more killing blows.

It was frustrating to all of us at first, this game takes a while to get a hang of. Most of us started with Native where you already have a "max level" char and are on equal playing ground (except the player skill). Also, the average cRPG player is better than the average Native, so I can imagine it must be quite frustrating to come here and get your ass handed to you 24/7.

Stick with it, practice and you'll eventually become good, how much time depending on your talent.

What Slovenian said.

Also, since you are new to this, maybe we need to cover some basics.

If you don't want to be spammed you need to attack yourself. In order to do this properly, you need to learn to listen, not to watch. The moment you HEAR the weapon connecting with your shield, the same moment you need to attack. If they are spamming, use left to right swing and move to the right. This way you will never get spammed, not even by ninjas.

Before you do anything else, you need to plan your lvl 30 build. Your weapon of choice should depend on your build. There are people like kinngrimm who like to be very mobile and have a great footwork and using 12/24 build. If you are going for this kind of build you NEED pierce or blunt weapon. Others prefer to hit hard and go for 21/15. With 7 PS you can use whatever weapon you want, it wont glance. The most balanced is 18/18, which gives enough mobility, while it allows you to hit reasonably hard.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Dooz on March 29, 2012, 09:33:02 am
109 wpf might not even be giving you the minimum full potential (if that even makes sense) of the weapon, depending on how heavy your armor is. You can use the crpg calculator to plug in your armor weights and wpf, and it'll give you the effective wpf you're actually operating under. If it's below 100, you're blowin it. Ya blew it. I loved her. Ya blew it.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Malaclypse on March 29, 2012, 10:22:21 am
If it's below 100, you're blowin it. Ya blew it. I loved her. Ya blew it.

hahaha. Fucking Dooz, I love you. Ya blew it.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on March 29, 2012, 12:40:05 pm
I know Im kind of judging this before getting 'good' at it, but Im really feeling at the brute end of the stick for this.  I've roughed it out through peasant up to level 22 now, and I wouldn't call myself a shabby gamer, but too often it feels like Im just cannon fodder.  Only really good for standing at a flag in Siege.

Oddly my less savy friend who plays this seems to be doing better than me.  I don't want to say it's because he's using a two hander, and Im using one hander, but I out perform him in any other game that requires more twitch based skill.

It's very frustrating, and Im trying to learn, but it's feeling far more work than worth right now.

There's very valuable information in this thread, memorize it and use it.
I've played (including respecs and halfways to level 32) about 10 gens as a 1h/shielder now and unless you're good at positioning/know your reach/good manual blocking, you will have a hard time until you hit at least level 25. Level 25 is where you can have 15/15 stats, meaning 5 athletics, 5 shield skill and 5 PS.
For a first time shielder I would recommend a 21/15 build with 7 IF, PS and 5 ath/shield/wm. This build is forgiving with mistakes as you can take a few hits and you deal good damage with 7 PS.
There's a number of builds out there not including any WM, but I consider those builds suitable for the more experienced players. If you have trouble attacking back, the slight increase in attack speed from WM can make a difference.

For weapons the scimitars are a good choice, mainly because you don't have to worry about a stab just yet. The 1h stab is tricky and will glance a lot if you don't do it right. It can lead to a number of frustrating deaths. The damage will be fine when combined with the 7PS from the build mentioned above.

A good thing to do to improve your footwork is to go to the duelserver and find someone who kicks your ass over and over again by hitting you twice in a row. Often, if you ask them, they will help you to figure out a way to counter this. If they don't want to help just ask someone else. If you see a shielder do well, watch his movements closely, but most good one handers don't use their shield on the duel server.

Hope it helps :)
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vodner on March 29, 2012, 08:57:47 pm
Tried it out, still getting smoked by two handers, and pole arm users.
You're starting at a pretty painful time; most of the community is quite good at this point. Things will get better if you stick with it.

Duel is a decent place to learn footwork and blocking. It only takes a few seconds to go from dying to starting a new duel.

Quote
If it's below 100, you're blowin it. Ya blew it. I loved her. Ya blew it.
The speed and damage gained from WPF are linear. There isn't some threshold effect for dropping below 100. For example, going from 100 to 99 wpf will drop your damage output by 0.15%.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on March 29, 2012, 09:16:24 pm
The speed and damage gained from WPF are linear. There isn't some threshold effect for dropping below 100. For example, going from 100 to 99 wpf will drop your damage output by 0.15%.

You're right, but he means that you need at least 100 wpf to use the weapon with the stats listed on the website. Anything over 100 increases stats a bit and below 100 wpf gives you a penalty.

So get 100 effective wpf to get what you see on the website.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: zagibu on March 29, 2012, 10:11:54 pm
If you are level 22 and have 6 shield skill, it means you must have low strength. One handed with low strength is pretty useless, unless you have the hardest hitting weapons fully masterworked. You should read the offensive shielder guide, it's a bit outdated, but still contains valuable information. If you don't have MW weapons, I recommend you go for a 21/18 or 24/15 build with 7 or 8 PS respectively. If you use an unloomed steel pick or warhammer, you can get away with 18 STR imo. But I don't recommend these weapons, because they are too short.

And yes, it's true that 2h is much easier at first, because you do a lot of damage and have high reach, so you can get kills with stupid spam.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: LordSnow on March 30, 2012, 08:44:18 pm
I can give you one realy good advice. You have to use the mornigstar with your shield. You'll never get outspammed by two handers again.

Like a boss.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Mlekce on March 30, 2012, 09:00:55 pm
Yeah, that makes a ton of sense.

Alternatively, learn footwork, timing and use a long one handed sword.

are you fucking retarded or you are just trolling me? I wrote that he need to get more athletic and then get shorter weapon.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: [ptx] on March 30, 2012, 10:33:30 pm
No, you wrote that he fails because of reach and then suggested that he gets a shorter weapon.
It is absolutely not a retarded idea to suggest to a newbie to use a super short weapon that he will be struggling to hit enemies with :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on March 30, 2012, 10:36:43 pm
No, you wrote that he fails because of reach and then suggested that he gets a shorter weapon.
It is absolutely not a retarded idea to suggest to a newbie to use a super short weapon that he will be struggling to hit enemies with :rolleyes:

It was a speed issue I suffered from.  People with two handers hitting me before I hit them when Im basically hugging them.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on March 30, 2012, 10:42:49 pm
It was a speed issue I suffered from.  People with two handers hitting me before I hit them when Im basically hugging them.

2h swords will often sway from side to side to do whats called 'castoring' which can beat your swings.  DO not play their game, and try to not face hug them closely, but stay within your weapons range.  This will help you avoid the 'hiltslash' moves (getting hit by the first couple inches of a very long blade) that are taking advantage of weak game animations/mechanics

I would recommend you learn with a longer 1h weapon like a sword, dont go below 90 reach if you are learning.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Kafein on March 30, 2012, 10:58:38 pm
If you feel too slow, you don't use your left swing enough.

About 50% (just throwing numbers) of your close range moves should be left swings, the others being overheads or stabs if your weapon can stab. Never, never, never (never) in any circumstances use the right swing in any situation that does not force you to have a better reach than the left swing. Furthermore, it requires only minimal turning.

As other people said, a 1h with stab is a bad choice for a beginner, as it requires careful positioning and the most violent spinstabbing to avoid death sentence bounces.


Other than that, level 25 is not enough to grasp what you can really do with a shielder. You would be ok with a 2h or pole guy, because these ones have the easiest time getting cheap melee kills due to damage and reach advantages. So globally I would advise beginners to go 2h or polearm at first, because they won't really need to block that often if they stick with their team, and can do some killing faster.

Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: GauisMarius on March 31, 2012, 03:29:50 am
Lighter weight gear also helps I believe.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Son Of Odin on March 31, 2012, 03:50:00 am
Just don't listen to Mlecke. I think he hasn't quite figured out this problem himself either :mrgreen:
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: ZEE_BISHOP on March 31, 2012, 12:33:13 pm
Generally shielders are more team orientated, you'll be the guy distracting the enemy / saving friends / taking arrows to save others / leading the way in tricky defensive spots / surviving slightly longer in some situations. The average shielder will not get as many kills as the average 2H player.

I like the build 21/18 personally. 21/15 is a solid beginner build, but it's a team based build -- You will be kyted like hell by people and you will find yourself missing hits and being spammed.

People advise you to avoid 2Hers because they can out damage you, outspam you, outreach you and outrun you. Well, you can't avoid someone who comprises 70% of the melee force on your enemies side and can run faster than you due to not lugging a shield around. Sure, run away when you're outnumbered and stick with your team, but the reality is you need a bit more speed to deal with these people sooner or later.

You're inherently outclassed as a 1H. Your weapon, being lighter, will be stunned when blocking by heavier weapons. With its lower reach, you'll have to block at least 2 times when approaching someone with a 2H / pole arm weapon before you can hit them back. Your fastest and most used attack mode (left swing) is also incredibly predictable.

You need 18 AGI, 6 ath and 6 WM (if possible) to keep up with the big boys if you want to be able to stand on your own two feet on the battlefield (Do not get below 7 PS or you'll weep when using cutting weapons). Wearing lighter armour will make you a bit faster, but it's a double edged sword. You'll die faster and while "MY SHIELD IS MY ARMOUR HERP DERP" it's simply impossible to not get some hits when dancing around with a group on you. but 21/18 allows you to dodge and weave in group situations like a boss, it allows you to keep up with the big boys and deal serious damage when you get there and it allows you to bob in and out of combat with people who are used to being the fastest.

Get good at manual blocking and shove your shield on your back in 1v1 situations, especially vrs an axe user. Only use your shield when ranged are attacking you or you're taking on multiple people who you believe would get free hits on you if you were to manual block in that situation. Your shield slows you down, movement wise and swing wise.

Weapon wise, I prefer to get as close to or above 100 range as possible and the same with speed. Range will help with swing speed too, you'll find yourself moving forward a little less often which means you're not giving up your "swing turn" to the 2h'd AGI spammer backpeddling you meaning he cannot spam you with impunity. As others have said, weapons that don't stab are good starters such as the Elite scimitar or scimitar because you won't accidentally pop off a failed stab attack which will whiff and make you rage like a man possessed -- They're also fast, long and hit hard (they have the added bonus of being curved too which is deceptive and people misjudge your range, you seem to whiff less closer to people as well). Personally I like the Nordic war sword / Nordic champion sword.

It might be worth getting 2 throwing skill and 50~ wpf in throwing. You'll be amazed at how helpful a stack of war darts or a couple of francisca throwing axes is as a 1H player. You won't sacrifice too many skill points (maybe loose out on ironflesh and maybe drop to 4 shield skill). But what you'll gain is the ability to get kills on people from a distance (Granted, not often with that low throwing). But most importantly, you'll have the threat of range, this means you can let a AGI spamming back peddler walk back like the monkey that he is and pull out your throwing weapon. This puts him in a dilemma as he has to come back to you or leave you alone. Horses will avoid you like the plague too, and you'll have a handy weapon to kill or stun archers who are running away from you. Beware of the extra weight they cost though.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on March 31, 2012, 04:27:35 pm
dont bother with throwing for a generation or 2, just adds more complexity and you'll end up getting yourself killed far more often that you actually hit or kill enemies.

also the part about putting your shield on your back is crap.  leave that stupid stuff for the autoblockers. a GOOD shielder will rarely put his shield away.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: ZEE_BISHOP on April 01, 2012, 03:05:31 am
dont bother with throwing for a generation or 2, just adds more complexity and you'll end up getting yourself killed far more often that you actually hit or kill enemies.

also the part about putting your shield on your back is crap.  leave that stupid stuff for the autoblockers. a GOOD shielder will rarely put his shield away.

What are you talking about? A good 1 hander doesn't need to waste his shield in 1v1's. If you've taken a shield because you can't manual block, then you've chosen 1H for the wrong reasons. Sure waste your shield for no reason if you want, I guess the floor is littered with shields from 1H shielders who tried to chase back peddling 2H sworders
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on April 01, 2012, 03:11:30 am
What are you talking about? A good 1 hander doesn't need to waste his shield in 1v1's. If you've taken a shield because you can't manual block, then you've chosen 1H for the wrong reasons. Sure waste your shield for no reason if you want, I guess the floor is littered with shields from 1H shielders who tried to chase back peddling 2H sworders

guess you fail to take into account WHO is asking for advice.  telling a new player to put his shield on his back to fight 2h'er is about the stupidest advice you could give.

the advice is..dont chase fast 2h users.  Keep your shield up and look for teammates for help or just rope-e-dope until help arrives.  practice on duel server how to fight agi whore 2h'ers
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Jarlek on April 01, 2012, 03:20:33 am
Just gonna put it here. 2h is the easiest class. That simple. The only thing you need to learn is manual blocking (that being said, all classes need that, and it's pretty much M&B:Warband 101 to learn it), and that's it. It's also probably the best to learn the game with, because it forces you to learn to manual block, you can still help out, even though you are bad, and it is more forgiving with mistakes.

And to the people I know are gonna complain...

No. I am not saying 2h is OP, or eazymode or anything. All I'm saying is that it's the easiest class, to do "well" in. The class you need the least skill in to still be useful. The end.

For the record: The class that is the MOST powerful in the hands of a super-player, would be polearm. It's slightly harder, but can also be slightly more effective. I'm a 1h/archer, btw.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Teeth on April 01, 2012, 05:50:51 pm
Just gonna put it here. 2h is the easiest class.The only thing you need to learn is manual blocking, and that's it.
It's not that easy. I remember being amazed at two last players of a team, top players, exchanging a dozen swings and blocking the bulk of em. The chat was filled with people saying 'wow, how the fuck do you do that?' The average manual blocking skill slowly increased to the ridiculously high point where its at now. For months after the release shielder was by far the easiest class, even disregarding the missile blocking capabilities.

For a new player to become an effective 2h takes hours and hours of practice. Whereas being effective at ranged takes a handful of hours to adapt to the missile speed and the missile drop. Its just that this game is addictive as crack that most people easily spend hundreds of hours into this game and learn blocking very well.

The class you need the least skill in to still be useful. The end.
This is just complete bullshit. Give a new player a 2h and he will die as soon as he is targeted, give a new player a shield and he does much better. Or a horse and a lance for that matter. Or a bow or crossbow.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: rustyspoon on April 01, 2012, 05:58:07 pm
It's not that easy. I remember being amazed at two last players of a team, top players, exchanging a dozen swings and blocking the bulk of em. The chat was filled with people saying 'wow, how the fuck do you do that?' The average manual blocking skill slowly increased to the ridiculously high point where its at now. For months after the release shielder was by far the easiest class, even disregarding the missile blocking capabilities.

For a new player to become an effective 2h takes hours and hours of practice. Whereas being effective at ranged takes a handful of hours to adapt to the missile speed and the missile drop. Its just that this game is addictive as crack that most people easily spend hundreds of hours into this game and learn blocking very well.
This is just complete bullshit. Give a new player a 2h and he will die as soon as he is targeted, give a new player a shield and he does much better. Or a horse and a lance for that matter. Or a bow or crossbow.

Still, I  recommend that new players start with 2handers. Sure, you'll die a lot more but you'll become a better player faster than if you are a 1-hander.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: [ptx] on April 01, 2012, 07:52:45 pm
This is just complete bullshit. Give a new player a 2h and he will die as soon as he is targeted, give a new player a shield and he does much better. Or a horse and a lance for that matter. Or a bow or crossbow.
I wouldn't say that. A newbie shielder is easily the least dangerous class in the game. Most of those can't even return attacks and mostly just get in the way of their allies, being more of a burden than a boon to their team. A newbie 2her can jump into a clusterfuck and hit stuff for lots of damage.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: enigmatic_stranger on April 01, 2012, 08:17:05 pm
1h left swing can be very fast. Footwork do the trick...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eso06QNS4e8&feature=player_detailpage#t=15s
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on April 01, 2012, 09:50:06 pm
I wouldn't say that. A newbie shielder is easily the least dangerous class in the game. Most of those can't even return attacks and mostly just get in the way of their allies, being more of a burden than a boon to their team. A newbie 2her can jump into a clusterfuck and hit stuff for lots of damage.

I would disagree, even if they dont do much damage they can contribute more than some noob 2h who is teamhitting allies in large melee's or dies in 1 hit because he cant block.  With shield you can serve as a distraction, box/pin people in for allies to kill and be that annoying zombie that wont die until you get the time to lurch forward and take a bite.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Fazar on April 02, 2012, 08:22:33 pm
Level 24 now, and starting to actually contribute.  The left swing thing I never knew about and has helped me the most so far.  I still get rocked by most people, but I get the occasional archer kill, or lucky kill on some person I believe to be 30.

I made the mistake of throwing some points into throwing which Im regretting now, hoping I had thrown that all into one handed more.  Got like 129 weapon proficiency, and still wear light armour/lightshield.  Been trying the Italian sword now instead of the Nordic Short.  It's not as bad as it was when I started, but I think Im going to try two hander next Gen.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: San on April 02, 2012, 08:38:18 pm
Watch out for when you want to right swing.

Speed, low range: left-swing
Decent speed and range: overhead (prone to miss at times)
Range, low speed: right-swing (prone to glance at times if the opponent moves to your right at a bad angle)

Stabs take practice, but the best users make the stab look fast and with quite a bit of range such as Saul or Kartoffelin(sp?), although chances of messing up are fairly high.

If you're a little and you do right swing, don't move forward but strafe left. That usually helped me more often than not.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on April 03, 2012, 07:39:41 pm
Level 24 now, and starting to actually contribute.  The left swing thing I never knew about and has helped me the most so far.  I still get rocked by most people, but I get the occasional archer kill, or lucky kill on some person I believe to be 30.

I made the mistake of throwing some points into throwing which Im regretting now, hoping I had thrown that all into one handed more.  Got like 129 weapon proficiency, and still wear light armour/lightshield.  Been trying the Italian sword now instead of the Nordic Short.  It's not as bad as it was when I started, but I think Im going to try two hander next Gen.

129 is pretty damn good actually.  I'm a polearm/1h hybrid and I leave my 1h at 100 and I still do very good with it when I'm using my shield.  Stick with it, my first generation I went 253 deaths before getting a kill, now when I start my new gens I usually have a kill by turn 15 (and more importantly I actually feel useful), and I had a c-rpg veteran guiding me the whole way...Next gen I'd suggest using a pitch fork until you can wield a boar spear and just poke people when you can to interrupt their timing for teammates (and you can rear horses too).  You don't even necessarily need to put WPF into polearms to still be useful early on.  And since these weapons have pierce damage you being really weak means you can still do some damage to people.

If you can, try to befriend someone in game, or better yet, befriend someone in a faction, ask if you can hang in their team speak or ventrilo and when you have questions you can just ask.

Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Teeth on April 03, 2012, 08:36:19 pm
Stick with it, my first generation I went 253 deaths before getting a kill
Hmm, lets see. 253 deaths is 253 rounds, let's say the average round takes 4 minutes. That is 1012 minutes or 16,9 hours of gameplay without a kill. With an average multiplier of 2 that brings you at level 26.

That long until your first kill is not really normal.

Ontopic: 129 wpf is fine, that should not be the problem. The combat system is hard to learn and has a quite a bit of things you need to know. I can really recommend that you join a clan, they can show you the ropes a lot faster and you can ask questions. Being in a clan enhances the game anyway.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on April 03, 2012, 09:34:35 pm
Hmm, lets see. 253 deaths is 253 rounds, let's say the average round takes 4 minutes. That is 1012 minutes or 16,9 hours of gameplay without a kill. With an average multiplier of 2 that brings you at level 26.

That long until your first kill is not really normal.

I didn't say it was normal.  And I'm pretty sure I played a lot of siege early on.  I can tell you I for sure wasn't level 26.  I believe it was level 20 or 22.  My point wasn't that it was normal, my point was that it was horrible, but I've grown into what I consider a pretty good player.  My 2nd point was that it still took me 253 deaths before a kill and I had my bro helping me with my build and gear (who is a veteran crpg player), so I wasn't coming in completely blind.  I also was saving money for a cavalry build, so I'm sure I was using a pitch fork for a lot of my early levels.

The point was to indicate how hard it can be to get accustomed to C-rpg, even if you have someone walking you through how it works. 

Once you get over the initial learning curve it's exponentially easier. 
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Xant on April 03, 2012, 10:03:22 pm
I wouldn't say that. A newbie shielder is easily the least dangerous class in the game. Most of those can't even return attacks and mostly just get in the way of their allies, being more of a burden than a boon to their team. A newbie 2her can jump into a clusterfuck and hit stuff for lots of damage.

Yep. Newbie shielders are the easiest to spam and kill. And then they think the game's broken.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Son Of Odin on April 03, 2012, 10:17:18 pm
Yep. Newbie shielders are the easiest to spam and kill. And then they think the game's broken.
That is so fun fun fun! Especially with my loomed long war axe. They wonder what the hell hit them because there is nothing they can do to stop me.

Bam bam bam! 3 hits to shield --> shield gone ---> nab cant manualblock --> DEATH.

Or Bam! one hit to shield ---> shielder thinks he has the turn to hit me (wroooong) ---> epic skillz feintspam, right footwork and right slash to the face ---> repeat ---> Dead shielder.

------> shielder runs to forums to complain the game is broken --> win and smile
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Jarlek on April 04, 2012, 02:46:42 am
Yep. Newbie shielders are the easiest to spam and kill. And then they think the game's broken.
Yup. Shielder is the worst class for new guys.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on April 04, 2012, 04:38:49 am
Yup. Shielder is the worst class for new guys.

If you like learning parts of game at a time and a less steep learning curve, shields are great.  If you like getting throw into trial by fire and having an even more frustrating learning period that not having a shield is just for you
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: rustyspoon on April 04, 2012, 02:10:25 pm
If you like learning parts of game at a time and a less steep learning curve, shields are great.  If you like getting throw into trial by fire and having an even more frustrating learning period that not having a shield is just for you

The thing is though, axes are REALLY popular now. A newbie will have their shield break in 2-3 swings. If you're new to this game a 1-hander without a shield is pretty much the worst position you could be in. Also, new players with shields like to turtle up, which is the complete wrong way to play this game. You'll just get spammed until you die. I know I do it to new players all the time.

If they at least start with 2-h or pole they'll have more points to invest in their character and a longer weapon that does more damage. They also won't learn any bad habits about turtling up.

1h is overall my favorite class to play, but there is a reason why most of the shitty players you run into are 1-handers.

Due to 1-handers being so short and having a tiny sweetspot combined with lower damage and slower movement speed because of shields and point investment; footwork is crucial to do decent as a 1-hander. Footwork isn't something you learn overnight, unlike blocking.

You can spend a few hours learning to block and be able to match up to the average player.

I'm not saying 1-hander is harder than other classes, ('cause seriously how hard is it to left swing) just saying that to get to a moderate level, the learning curve is much better on 2-handers/polearms and will make you a better player overall.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Rainbow on April 04, 2012, 10:21:18 pm
I have some advice nobody has given.  Join a clan that will teach you how to fight.  If you are interested, I will make you my apprentice and teach you everything I know with some one on one duels.  I have never trained anybody except saulcanner but I will take you on.  Let me know.  I am in clan TKoV.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: rustyspoon on April 05, 2012, 01:45:53 am
I have some advice nobody has given.  Join a clan that will teach you how to fight.  If you are interested, I will make you my apprentice and teach you everything I know with some one on one duels.  I have never trained anybody except saulcanner but I will take you on.  Let me know.  I am in clan TKoV.

I can attest to Rainbow's fantastic training methods.

This is me after going through his course:
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: zagibu on April 05, 2012, 08:10:55 pm
I can attest to Rainbow's fantastic training methods.

This is me after going through his course:
(click to show/hide)

Wow, you have lost 80 pounds in his course?
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: rustyspoon on April 06, 2012, 12:48:55 am
Wow, you have lost 80 pounds in his course?

Yep. All of it from my head.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Piok on April 06, 2012, 04:50:35 pm
In my opinion chadz text is all what matters. When I started to play Crpg my swings on lvl25+ were slower then now on lvl 1.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Xant on April 06, 2012, 07:35:08 pm
chadz text doesn't... improve your swingspeed. at all.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Corwin on April 06, 2012, 08:32:19 pm
chadz text doesn't... improve your swingspeed. at all.


lol, Xant.

I think you 've been trolled hard.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Piok on April 06, 2012, 09:53:37 pm
chadz text doesn't... improve your swingspeed. at all.
maybe but this doesn't explain strange slowness of beginners  even with balanced builds.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Jarlek on April 06, 2012, 10:04:38 pm
maybe but this doesn't explain strange slowness of beginners  even with balanced builds.
Player skill?
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Piok on April 06, 2012, 10:19:13 pm
Player skill?
and how player skill affect swing speed. I know that turning into swing helps a little but my swinging speed is faster than it was at beginning almost year ago.
So my conclusion is there must be something else which is affecting swing speed not only wpf and chadz text is very unpredictable.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on April 06, 2012, 10:24:26 pm
and how player skill affect swing speed. I know that turning into swing helps a little but my swinging speed is faster than it was at beginning almost year ago.
So my conclusion is there must be something else which is affecting swing speed not only wpf and chadz text is very unpredictable.
How chadtext happens is unpredictable, what it does is not.

It gives you 3 crafting skill in each item you have equipped when you get the message.  And it gives -1 crafting skill for every item you already have a skill in.  This is strictly for strategus.

Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Piok on April 06, 2012, 10:57:32 pm
How chadtext happens is unpredictable, what it does is not.

It gives you 3 crafting skill in each item you have equipped when you get the message.  And it gives -1 crafting skill for every item you already have a skill in.  This is strictly for strategus.
I don't play strat. But I've started with mount and musket and i don't see any slowness here. Then I was captured by crpg. From start I was wondering why was my swing speed so slow even with 140 wpf.
So I make ninja(agiwhore) char 12/27 and start backstabbing and it work good until soak change in armor, so i returned to balanced build but slowness remained. After returning to standard builds I begun to duel a bit trying feints and in that time first chadz text begin to appear. After 2 or so chadz txt I've noticed  small improvement in swing speed.

But if it's not chadz text then maybe skillz  :mrgreen:. Btw I have no masterskills still I swing faster then in beginning :shock:.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Rainbow on April 06, 2012, 11:26:36 pm
I can attest to Rainbow's fantastic training methods.

This is me after going through his course:
(click to show/hide)

LOL>  That was great.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: //saxon on April 07, 2012, 12:14:53 am
I don't play strat. But I've started with mount and musket and i don't see any slowness here. Then I was captured by crpg. From start I was wondering why was my swing speed so slow even with 140 wpf.
So I make ninja(agiwhore) char 12/27 and start backstabbing and it work good until soak change in armor, so i returned to balanced build but slowness remained. After returning to standard builds I begun to duel a bit trying feints and in that time first chadz text begin to appear. After 2 or so chadz txt I've noticed  small improvement in swing speed.

But if it's not chadz text then maybe skillz  :mrgreen:. Btw I have no masterskills still I swing faster then in beginning :shock:.
lol it isnt chadz text never has been.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Vibe on April 07, 2012, 04:34:29 pm
I don't play strat. But I've started with mount and musket and i don't see any slowness here. Then I was captured by crpg. From start I was wondering why was my swing speed so slow even with 140 wpf.
So I make ninja(agiwhore) char 12/27 and start backstabbing and it work good until soak change in armor, so i returned to balanced build but slowness remained. After returning to standard builds I begun to duel a bit trying feints and in that time first chadz text begin to appear. After 2 or so chadz txt I've noticed  small improvement in swing speed.

But if it's not chadz text then maybe skillz  :mrgreen:. Btw I have no masterskills still I swing faster then in beginning :shock:.

so dense
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: San on April 08, 2012, 10:02:44 pm
I think I'm starting to get the hang of right swing again to the point where it's about as good as I could do it back last fall.

(For str builds at least it works) As long as you move forward, then strafe left while you swing, no forward motion, you can hit more often than not with a little bit of turning. It's still pretty risky since right swing is so dang slow at times.

Right swing and stab takes a lot of practice to be large threats.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: ZEE_BISHOP on April 11, 2012, 05:39:19 pm
guess you fail to take into account WHO is asking for advice.  telling a new player to put his shield on his back to fight 2h'er is about the stupidest advice you could give.

the advice is..dont chase fast 2h users.  Keep your shield up and look for teammates for help or just rope-e-dope until help arrives.  practice on duel server how to fight agi whore 2h'ers

Quite frankly, this is the worst advice for a new player I can think of. What you're advising a new guy to do is turtle up -- He learns nothing from that and dies constantly for his pains. You're setting a new guy up to become someone who moans on the forum about how unfair it is that the speed isn't right.

If he tries manual blocking and doesn't crutch on his shield constantly to block when he doesn't have to, then yes, he absolutely will die to more experienced players. However, he will learn to manual block in the process and will get a much better grasp of how the game plays out. As a 1Her you need to block a 2Her twice to get into their range and be able to actually swing -- If you have a shield up too, you're looking at 3 blocks before you can hit back and remember you'll be chasing them as you do it and giving up your swing turns to move slowly after them.

I would say out of any class, ironically, the shielder is the person who should be most adapt at manual blocking. Axe users and 2H sworders will lay waste to you if you think it's a good plan to go attempt swinging back with anything lower than 6 athletics behind you. Your shield's going to disappear pretty damn fast and you're going to have no clue what to do.

And as I said above, the advice "lol well avoid 2H / axe users then! HUAEHAUHE" is completely infeasible -- They make up 70%+ of the melee population and you're absolutely a key target for them to lolspam with impunity. You move slower than them and a turtling shielder moves even slower, he's looked at as a free kill and they will swarm from all over to kill you.

I mean, I agree, ideally you should avoid them and run away to your team but that's simply not possible a lot of the time. The longer you leave it to learn how to deal with people like that, the more pain and anguish you're going to go through. Sure, practice with the tutorial how to manual block, and practice on the duel server how to chase AGI whores too.

A shielder doesn't have to get kills to be a valuable part of the team, distracting people is handy too or taking an arrow or a melee hit to the shield to save another guy is awesome as well. At the end of the day, your team wins by killing the other team. Not to mention... You know, actually enjoy the game somewhat.

I also agree with other people that 2H is the easiest class for a new guy -- In fact, the easiest class for anyone to play. A good 2H takes a lot of skill, however the average retard flailing with a 2H sword can quite easily top the scoreboard. You move fast, hit crazy hard, have the longest reach and can swing quite fast too. You've got a wide array of variously priced weapons and you're able to wear heavier armour. dodging arrows is something a monkey could pick up after a week and while you might be more prone to die if you're aggressive and don't know how to block, you're also able to get out of dangerous situations easier. Not to mention a 2Her can carry a shield too if he wants.

I started off as a 2H -- I played every class and have been playing 1H for ages now. Out of all the classes, it's one of the trickiest to play well.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Spawny on April 11, 2012, 06:07:25 pm
I started off as a 2H -- I played every class and have been playing 1H for ages now. Out of all the classes, it's one of the trickiest to play well.

Couldn't agree more :)
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: Digglez on April 11, 2012, 09:20:56 pm
Quite frankly, this is the worst advice for a new player I can think of. What you're advising a new guy to do is turtle up -- He learns nothing from that and dies constantly for his pains. You're setting a new guy up to become someone who moans on the forum about how unfair it is that the speed isn't right.

If he tries manual blocking and doesn't crutch on his shield constantly to block when he doesn't have to, then yes, he absolutely will die to more experienced players. However, he will learn to manual block in the process and will get a much better grasp of how the game plays out. As a 1Her you need to block a 2Her twice to get into their range and be able to actually swing -- If you have a shield up too, you're looking at 3 blocks before you can hit back and remember you'll be chasing them as you do it and giving up your swing turns to move slowly after them.

Good job generalizing way too much.  First thing I teach my shielders is left swing counter attacking, and to NOT turtle up.

Get a long 1h sword and pull back a right swing, learn your range and timing and see how many 2h axes wanna play ball.  You can keep them at bay for quite awhile.  Learn how to do a few change up feigns into leftswing or overhead, that shit isnt rocket science...and about 100x easier than learning to manual parry.  Learning with a shield doubles your average life expectancy.  Noobie 2h'ers are pretty worthless on the other hand.
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: hippy_with_a_scimi on April 12, 2012, 12:39:49 am
Good job generalizing way too much.  First thing I teach my shielders is left swing counter attacking, and to NOT turtle up.

Get a long 1h sword and pull back a right swing, learn your range and timing and see how many 2h axes wanna play ball.  You can keep them at bay for quite awhile.  Learn how to do a few change up feigns into leftswing or overhead, that shit isnt rocket science...and about 100x easier than learning to manual parry.  Learning with a shield doubles your average life expectancy.  Noobie 2h'ers are pretty worthless on the other hand.

to most a shielder is : 1- a noob
                                   2- unable to manual block
                                   3- a scumbag turtler
                                   4- a leftswing spammer
or all of the above :D

some say its easy to be a 1hand shielder , its true to some extent.. but there is a huge difference with the average easy shielder and a really good shielder 
Title: Re: Why is my One Handed so slow?
Post by: zagibu on April 12, 2012, 10:39:25 pm
Surviving might be easy as a shielder, but killing is not, especially when you are new.