NA2 rotation has had the same treatment as EU2 for the past years, with some minor changes sometimes done by shik.
There was indeed a thread where NA players were discussing why it was dying (or being dead rather). That thread was mostly about clan stacking/str crutchers or "bring back ATS maps" (which for most part were horrible). Meanwhile, EU had no problem sustaining and increasing it's population.
Bottom line is, siege map rotation or even maps are not the reason "NA2 is dying", if it were we would see the same happening in EU. Clearly, this is not the case.
dontgothere, you seem frustrated, angry and honestly a bit silly. Calm down.
It's not just that mistakes were made, it's that people gave you solutions and were completely ignored. The feedback was there, the alternatives were there, and the badmins just hid behind an attitude just like you're doing now.
This is a complete and blatant lie. A figment of your imagination I gather. Projecting your frustration with angry posts is not the same as being constructive.
Most post done in a constructive manner in Scene Editing have been answered and Very Often also resulted in a change. I dare say that it's the most progressive part of the dev team when it comes to player input.