According to the archives your only wins are from:
http://c-rpg.net/?page=strategusinfobattledetail&id=1205#!?page=strategusinfobattledetail&id=1205 (taking a village with 8 defenders)
and the one time taking of Dashigba, which I was there for. (maybe you speak of strat 2 as well?)
Tismirr and Dashbigha twice, according to my battle list.
I'm still a firm believer that everyone's got their own strategy/mindset about castle sieges. Just because you have x amount of battles under your belt doesn't make you more or less qualified to give your opinion on something.
Understandable, I wasn't attacking you either, merely questioning your own logic. (since you seem to be ready to talk about it, but I've never truly seen it.)
I was just wondering why you don't seem to adhere to your own logic since you seem always eager to offer your insight on strat matters when you haven't really been relevant in strat affairs for many months.
I could ask you the very same question.
And on that note, Ulburban was initially my first choice for my sneak attack on the free traders, but ultimately ended up choosing Tismirr for...other reasons. Perhaps you would heed my advice had you seen the mighty disciples in action. There is always time for that though.
Ah yes, you're not the only one who has planned to attack my wonderful village. I still eagerly await any form of advance, and I assume you're the closest to actually launching any form of attack and for that I nod in acknowledgement. Tismirr is quite a nice village to attack, I'm unsure of Ulburban though.
I'd love to sit down and have a conversation with you sometime, JC, it seems to me that we see eye to eye on many subjects. Unfortunately, it appears we've taken off on the wrong foot.
Edit:
Our active player base has been low lately, but we've been working on it and now that we've got some people on board who knows what sort of magical adventure could come our way?