Actually you are wrong about this. Remember all those threads with people doing the exact same mistake, other guy refused to give it back, and admins permabanned them? That is what would have happened if he hadn't given the item back. Also, it's not a ~1M profit when you get it because of a typo mistake by the other guy. It's scamming. Also, we just threw the "pay us the money and we will leave you alone" because they started begging us to stop attacking them in strat, and we wanted some fun with them. Nothing wrong with that, no? Besides, he is the one bringing this all up again, remember? We're just explaining shit to ya 
Well as you seem to want it I will reply.
I agree with you, except on one, rather big, thing.
It's scamming.
It is not. Not at any moment did the so-called scammer lied. Hell, he did not even communicate at all. I also don't remember a single thread about someone that was banned for accepting a trade with a typo in it. The
actual scammers (those that for example say they sell heirloom points but just keep the item you want them to loom) are dealt with
as such, since the beginning of the marketplace. The only consequence of events similar to this was poophammer losing his admin status.
