Bully is limited and mechanically not all that great.
LA Noire is a technical mess (30 FPS hard lock makes it horrible), offers the best collection of 40s cars but the driving sim is worse than mario kart. Really, anything action related in that game is horrible. The big story arc is meh, but the individual cases were mostly interesting. The Black Dahlia arc especially has a couple of plot holes if you do it in some particular way, and on top of that Cole and Cole's chief have Leshma's emotional stability.
I hear RDR is really good, but I didn't play it.