Muki, let's run this one again.
Nemesis posts that Cap was a "bad person". Not a bannable offense. You check logs, he kills someone who has killed V (Jerry). It's all in the chat, it's obvious we were forming a ring around V to stop this V killer. Jerry, the kid who died (For Killing V), does not post on the forums asking for Cap to be banned. He'd get himself banned if he did, for killing V.
4 people do post, stating Cap only killed him because he was killing the V. The kid Cap Tk'd makes no appearance or demands. ProjectNemesis does post, demanding Cap's ban, but as you yourself state, you have no idea what he's talking about.
The only people who post back up Cap's story. You ban him based on log showing him killing someone who was actually greifing. You state you cannot ban Jerry, for lack of evidence. Yet you can ban Cap, with no evidence except his past history?
Am I to understand if someone is killing the virgin, with VK disabled, and no admin coming into the server, we are supposed to let them ruin our play experience because we'll be banned based on just killing them alone, and a "lack of evidence" when 4 people who were actually there post in our defense?
This game is far too Ban happy. Honestly. There is a huge difference between trolling/griefing, and what people are banned for on a regular basis.
I still can't believe you banned him for him TKing Jerry, a known virgin killer. The whole server knew it and observed him for like, 7 straight rounds, doing nothing but using his higher AGI to run away, circle back, and hit V, repeatedly, with us having to defend V from him AND the NPCs. Can your Log system show you the scores people had at the time of a kill? I am pretty sure they can't. How are you going to even say our "club" was not defending V or killing any of the Bots we were "helping to spawn" when you don't actually know?