New Teamwounding Report System

[CrazyCracka420]

they coul add reporting for bumps that do damage (if possible) but also attacks on a horse should be reportable

both would be nice i hate carefully leaving spawn to avoid infantry only to have some douche bag take my horse down to 3/4 health.

[Leesin]

I haven't had a single report against me, yet I still think it's a massively retarded system, this is the cRPG community, it wont be long before we start seeing 'trolls' purposely getting in the way of their team mates attacks so they can report them.

[Overdriven]

Resolved:
0000035
    [cRPG] Friendly horsebump doesn't count as a teamwound   
Warband - multiplayer - [ingame] - 2012-01-02 20:27

*scowl*

However:

0000027
    [cRPG] the first teamwound report (1/5) will only be shown to both sides   
Warband - multiplayer - [ingame] - 2011-12-31 13:45

[MrShine]

I just want to say that the introduction of horse bumps counting and less reporting spam being seen by most players goes a long way towards cleaning things up with the system. I think once 0 damage punches and glances aren't reportable it will make things even better.

 I still stand by my feelings this feature has the potential to become a troll's playground once people start to figure it all out.  I also still see a lot more "clanmate A has reported clanmate B" spam than actual intentional team wounding, and have myself reported a teammate once out of rage after their careless swing lead to my death (and I'm a generally level headed player that follows the rules so if I am prone to this a good chunk of the population are twice as likely to do this as myself).   But if this isn't going away at least it looks like it is starting to move in a better direction.

[B3RS3RK]

That system is fucking confusing and retarded as shit.
Please remove it.

[_Tak_]

No its good in battle due to stupid team cavalry keep bumping me for no reason. But please remove it in siege or make it 5 times get kick instead of 3 because people keep report me, and it is so easy to hit team mate in siege...

[Gisbert_of_Thuringia]

No its good in battle due to stupid team cavalry keep bumping me for no reason. But please remove it in siege or make it 5 times get kick instead of 3 because people keep report me, and it is so easy to hit team mate in siege...

1. It is five ticks
2. Learn to play? How comes other people can play siege without getting kicked for teamhitting? ;)

[woody]

Maybe its anti the popular view but I think this should strengthened.

In addition to current every team hit should have gold/xp penalty as auto.

[bonekuukkeli]

Maybe it just needs some time... so people get used to it and maybe learn to understand what word intentional means.

I haven't been kicked from server and never went past 2/5 so system is working quite well. To get 5/5 you need to do quite a lot of teamdamage to other players in my opinion. Not everyone reports...

Sure this leads to some trolls hitting teammates a bit to piss them off (and I know it's quite hard not to hit back), but we had them even before this report system and that's something what admins need to look at. Maybe make it 5/5 is kick, come back and repeat = ban.

[Cepeshi]

Reporting system is fine xcept idiots who are stepping behind you to stop your overhead and THEN report you, fucking retarded. Swings or contacts for 0dmg should not be reportable.

[Tears of Destiny]

Reporting system is fine xcept idiots who are stepping behind you to stop your overhead and THEN report you, fucking retarded. Swings or contacts for 0dmg should not be reportable.

Nothing like throwing down and deploying a ladder and being reported for it because it brushed a team mate... Seriously amusing.

[Leesin]

Nothing like throwing down and deploying a ladder and being reported for it because it brushed a team mate... Seriously amusing.

This is just one of the many lame situations that can get you reported, and to think that they are planning on making it so if you get 5/5 you get temp banned instead of just being kicked. Especially as I have already pointed out people can purposely get in your way and get hit by you ( even easier if you are on a horse, they can just jump infront of you ) and give you reports. How fun.

[Kampfkarotte]

Just played on EU_2 siege server on a map where my horse is very useful. I had a nice K/D of about 15-3 and then suddenly got kicked by this new report system.  As you know, never bumping a teammate with horse is impossible, especially when using a sword (and not lance). I play this game for one and a half year now and i am neither a teamkiller nor a noob and in my opinion it is really unfair when you get kicked by noobs who always press M and dont think about it. It worked really fine before this! Mostly there is an admin who kicks or bans real teamkillers/wounders and then there are still the good old polls if there is no admin. WE DONT NEED THIS REPORTING SYSTEM!!!

[SixThumbs]

I think the system is more useless than anything else, if someone is intentionally team-wounding I'm going to avoid them and if I team-wound someone else it's certainly not intentional and largely unavoidable in some situations if it happens. When I'm in the thick of a battle the message pops up and it really is just more of a distraction then anything.

There's been no perceived benefits of the system but I did play a round of siege and as I was trying to break down a door someone came up behind me and prevented me from doing so reporting me each time, then with a multi in a skirmish for the flag I accidentally hit someone after killing 3 of 6 enemies and the person hits "m" and I'm booted for no reason.

[Yxleif]

I like the reporting system, sure some people report for anything but most dont and it helps a lot with many abusers who just rides over anything to get that precious kill, shoot into melee containing mostly friendlies, "friendlies" standing on ladders kicking, tards just swinging wildly in melee and never caring who they hit etc.

I th and tk occasionally but I try hard to avoid it and I´ve never been kicked even with ragereporting. Nor do I report accidental th/tk, frankly I think this concept has a lot of merit.