If posting a single-minded view in a wall of text is writing 'everybody to the ground'. Than yes, that is a quality.
In theory, there is no 'best' or 'perfect' admin, different situations call for different roles and positions. Also called the contingency approach, this means that even c-rpg needs people that show that foolish behaviour does not go unpunished. While it also needs people who show others the respects they deserve for playing this mod, something even the devs sometimes forget.
there is no "deserved respect for playing this mod"
there is just respect among human beings... and respect is earned by actions... and is totally relative to one person's mentality. we all have our pool of people we know and there is who have more respect, who have less. My opinion about poophammer is still neutral. i never saw/knew he did something wrong, but also i don't know much about him. About buying a underpriced item on the market, there is no "deuche" attitude or moral offense in my opinion.
about respect, a whole clan asking for a punishment about something like this, just lost a bit of my respect... (don't know if it's worth much, but is what i think of.)