The List.

[Glyph]

i agree on the points most others do, the ones that make sence and that should already be in the mod. but the horse getting killed because of a bump is retarded, it's not realistic and will totally kill 1handed cav, so stay off my class!

[Overdriven]

Cav changes are dumb.

As are most of these in general. And no, I'm not writing a long arse post to explain why. Plenty of people can see from first glance why.

[Glyph]

it is very clear that you're a my old friendcher, a lot of the changes would really help my old friendchers, especially the cav changes

[Fluffy_Muffin]

TLDR - rubbish suggestions from another whiner, move along nothing to see here

[Bulzur]

Since there's no more bamboo spear, long spear, and pike, how do you expect infantry to survive when facing a lancer with his couched lance ?
Overall, some good ideas already suggested but not accepted/done because of the warband engine :
-horsemen receiving damage based on horse speed, when the horse dies
-xbow on the back needs to be reloaded before being used
-more time needed to sheath a weapon (unsheating seems okay)
-no ladders for battles (or at least, i would have made it as : your own team can't destroy it's own ladders. Only the opposing team can. So if you put a ladder, it will stay till being destroyed by ennemies or till next round. Frustrating to come to the ladder and see the xbowuser on top of it destroying it, before calmly reloading/shooting again... )
-More interesting WM.

Some ideas a bit retarded though.

[Thucydides]

horses die if they horsebump too hard? More like slightly injured while trampling retards

[Tavuk_Bey]

gayest requests ever. patricia, die plox

[Jarlek]

Same, but 2 things stand out just by skimming it...

"Horses die if they knock someone over.
Infantry die if they get knocked over by a horse."

lol

Change your avatar, that pokemon is already owned by another player!

[[ptx]]

Yes, as I've said, this list will probably alienate most of the community because people are against change, specially in video games, you are just another one in the massive flock of alienated sheeps.

The fact that you provide absolutely no argument or don't elaborate on anything makes not even take you seriously, a quick oneliner for a post with 1000+ characters, fucking brilliant.

You don't provide any argument for your "suggestions", so why should he?

[TurmoilTom]

i agree on the points most others do, the ones that make sence and that should already be in the mod. but the horse getting killed because of a bump is retarded, it's not realistic and will totally kill 1handed cav, so stay off my class!

I'm with Berethorn on this one. I've finally read the whole post, and the cav changes are the biggest and, to me, the most ridiculous.
These changes would be a severe blow to (and might even, as Berethorn put it, "kill") 1 handed cavalry.

Change your avatar, that pokemon is already owned by another player!

Sorry, Zapper. I'll do that right now.

[Grey]

Long post by a new player it seems. New as in, doesn't have over 2000 hrs of Warband, 10 years of Mount and Blade, 2 years of crpg.

All these ideas seem fine, but most are not a possibility due to engine limitations, balance issues, and TBH, fun.

[Patricia]

I'm with Berethorn on this one. I've finally read the whole post, and the cav changes are the biggest and, to me, the most ridiculous.
These changes would be a severe blow to (and might even, as Berethorn put it, "kill") 1 handed cavalry.

Sorry, Zapper. I'll do that right now.

gayest requests ever. patricia, die plox

horses die if they horsebump too hard? More like slightly injured while trampling retards

TLDR - rubbish suggestions from another whiner, move along nothing to see here

it is very clear that you're a friendly archer, a lot of the changes would really help friendly archers, especially the cav changes

Cav changes are dumb.

As are most of these in general. And no, I'm not writing a long arse post to explain why. Plenty of people can see from first glance why.

i agree on the points most others do, the ones that make sence and that should already be in the mod. but the horse getting killed because of a bump is retarded, it's not realistic and will totally kill 1handed cav, so stay off my class!

I see that none of you guys actually read the entire god damned post, as I've said before, I already developped on the subject of horses and the bumping.

Just because I'm THAT nice, I'll copy paste it just for all of you wonderful guys!


Horses take damage if they occupy the space of infantry (i.e bumping).
Horses die if they knock someone over.
Infantry die if they get knocked over by a horse.

Replace with:
Horses are reduced to a light gallop, trot, walk, or are completely stopped when bumping/knocking over infantry depending on the horse.
Fix horse charge hitbox.

With maybe a certain amount of damage to the horse depending on the speed it goes.

Long post by a new player it seems. New as in, doesn't have over 2000 hrs of Warband, 10 years of Mount and Blade, 2 years of crpg.

All these ideas seem fine, but most are not a possibility due to engine limitations, balance issues, and TBH, fun.

If you consider a new player anyone who didn't play Warband for over 2000 hours, Mount and Blade for 10 years and cRPG for 2 years then sure, I do have close to 2000 hours, I do have 1 year of cRPG accumulated and I did play mount and blade for several years.

Since there's no more bamboo spear, long spear, and pike, how do you expect infantry to survive when facing a lancer with his couched lance ?
Overall, some good ideas already suggested but not accepted/done because of the warband engine :
-horsemen receiving damage based on horse speed, when the horse dies
-xbow on the back needs to be reloaded before being used
-more time needed to sheath a weapon (unsheating seems okay)
-no ladders for battles (or at least, i would have made it as : your own team can't destroy it's own ladders. Only the opposing team can. So if you put a ladder, it will stay till being destroyed by ennemies or till next round. Frustrating to come to the ladder and see the xbowuser on top of it destroying it, before calmly reloading/shooting again... )
-More interesting WM.

Some ideas a bit retarded though.

Couched lances are much much easier to deal with than actual thrusts from a long ass lance, also, awlpikes, bills, long voulges, etc will all still be available to kill horses.

[LordBerenger]

I support this!

[Malaclypse]

You can still play a decent lancer cav with the thrust of a War Spear, and the removal of Long Spear/Pike/Lance length poking weapons would leave awlpikes as the natural counter to that, only a bit longer than the War Spear, and nowhere near as long as a a pike.

 I have not read Patricia's post completely through, or I haven't retained a lot of it, but I definitely agree with a lot of these proposed changes. Crossbows losing their readied bolt is a great idea, in particular, saying that as a crossbowman. The slot system you proposed, also, seems like a great idea, and is something like what I was hoping for when the slot system was implemented in the first place. The only thing I can say I would not like to see is the removal of jumping, due to the chaos/fun factor provided by it, plus the great platforming opportunities.. I would miss it a lot. I feel like M&B without jumping would lose some of it's oom-pa-pa.

[Grey]

Couched lances are much much easier to deal with than actual thrusts from a long ass lance...

ROFL, that sentence renders your entire thread invalid, lance thrust is the single easiest thing to avoid, lance only cav who are not couching can ONLY backstab, since even those of us who daggers and other "noblock" items scoff at lancers when they try to stab, cavalry is ALREADY an ambush only class unless you have a plated charger and NOONE around has ANY polearm.

As to the removal of the long polearms, cause the shaft is also a hitbox: that applies to ALL weapons with a stab, and 2h abuse this broken mechanic much more than pike and spears do. Stop complaining that noone has read your entire post before replying: Most people wont bother, as soon as they see ONE ridiculous suggestion, they loose interest.

Also, try joining a gym or something if you really believe the jumping in crpg is cartoonish. I WOULD like to see plate armoured guys jumping only a few inches up, but as to low armoured guys, if you really think people cant jump that far....