At first I agree it sounds fun and like a good idea. But, people that have been banned, which I hear is not many, are banned because they repeatedly harrass, TK, and just don't give a fuck about rules and the cRPG community.
Pelting them with stones on a server sounds great, but they will expect that that is a temporary punishment.
When somebody is ready for ban, that someone needs to go. Permanently. Don't let em come in with the same email and revoke their serial number. Let them play on their computers and play the solo campaign, HAVE FUN!!!!! Besides it takes money and time to maintain such server, don't even waste a breath on those people.
You think when mobsters say they need to punish someone, they spank their bottom. No. Badabing badaboom! One in the head. They're gone. They never existed. And we, in the cRPG community can play the game on a server without ASSHOLES that need to be banned and we can have a good time and play a serious medieval combat game.
I'm here to have fun with mature people not cater and spoil DICKS that fuck up games for other people.