"That peasant's a spy!"
Many games have worked in a backstab feature, where a player is instantly killed.
I'm not suggesting an instant-kill weapon, because it would fit the pacing of warband and c-rpg, but a high pierce damage 1h dagger that cannot be used with a shield could introduce a new style of play.
Here is something along the lines I am thinking of
Type: 1h
Length: 47
Speed: 96
Swing Damage: 22c
Thrust: 48p
Cannot be used with shield
Cannot block
Slots: 1
Requirements: Not important at the moment
A player who uses this would have to be an exceptional chamber blocker and would have to sneak up on an opponent to get it used properly. This weapon could introduce an entire new class to the game.
I know 48p is high, but here are some arguments on why it would be balanced
1: Other weapons do as high as 43b un-heirloomed. 48p would not carry the same desirable knock-down effects
2: No crush through. The weapon can be blocked
3: No shield, and no blocking, making this weapon undesirable for a primary weapon
4: Length is shorter than hammers in the game
5: It takes a weapon slot
Don't burn me alive if you don't agree, but I think it would be a very cool weapon.
P.s. My main character is a polearm character, so don't go screaming bias