Justice for Rapist?

[Osiris]

http://news.sky.com/story/1136523/rapist-discovers-his-victim-had-hiv

A jailed rapist will discover this week whether he contracted HIV from his victim.

Richard Thomas, 27, collapsed when police informed him about his victim's medical status and is still waiting to hear if he has contracted the virus.

Thomas knew the woman and was aware that she has another illness but had not known about the HIV.

He was shocked when he was told and asked to be taken to hospital, Liverpool Crown Court heard.

He had let himself into her home in Leigh, Greater Manchester, uninvited in the middle of the night and she awoke to find him raping her from behind.

"She froze and no words were exchanged. He pulled up his shorts and left," said Harry Pepper, prosecuting.

HIV for rape? sounds like he gets what he deserves

[Miwiw]

Women's evil plan!

[Torben]

hopefully he gets his cock cut off, imagine an HIV positive rapist roaming the streets. or just kill him straight away.

[Lennu]

[Clockworkkiller]

Always wear protection before you rape
Trust me, I put the rapist in therapist

[Rumblood]

hopefully he gets his cock cut off, imagine an HIV positive rapist roaming the streets. or just kill him straight away.

Oh, but that would be inhumane 

You know, I would be all for castration for a rape conviction, except I have seen too often where a woman claims rape because she didn't want to get in trouble herself with a husband or boyfriend she cheated on, or parents found out, or she wants to hide behind her heavy drinking that led to her consenting, etc.

[GOBBLINKINGREATLEADER]

^

Women accusing men of rape is a fairly incentivized option compared to the alternatives for a lot of women without scruples in the right situation.

[Torben]

^

Women accusing men of rape is a fairly incentivized option compared to the alternatives for a lot of women without scruples in the right situation.

which ofc doesnt help the wrongfully accused man that gets his testicles amputated ^^

nah but ofc my statement above was considering a clear state of investigation.

[Scervo]

They're already suffering by spending time in jail if they get caught, plus its preventing them from doing it to anyone else while they're in there (unless youre talking about prison rape, which is more of an issue with the prison system than the sentence). Cutting their dick off too isn't gonna undo the emotional issues that it causes for the victim, so castration as a punishment would kinda just be arbitrary cruelty.

[Miwiw]

Great, castration of a man.. Great plan. A direct death would be much better imo. Better be dead than not even half a man. After all you will be alive shortly after again.

[Torben]

They're already suffering by spending time in jail if they get caught, plus its preventing them from doing it to anyone else while they're in there (unless youre talking about prison rape, which is more of an issue with the prison system than the sentence). Cutting their dick off too isn't gonna undo the emotional issues that it causes for the victim, so castration as a punishment would kinda just be arbitrary cruelty.

violent rape is a form of savagery that cannot be cured,  and a short stay in prison wont help the women and children in peril after the criminal is back in the streets.

germany is especially soft on rapists,  and it happens way too often that childrapists after extensive therapy come free and rape a child within weeks.

[Scervo]

If someone isn't suitable to be back out in society without committing the same crime again, keep them in prison while treating them mentally until they're stable enough not to; if they never reach that point, don't release them. Imo, they need mental help, not physical punishment. Their dick doesn't make the decision to rape someone, their mind does.

[Nehvar]

It would be absolutely hilarious if he does indeed contract HIV.  To top it off he won't get any sympathy from anyone...though I guess it will probably save him from being raped in prison.

[Clockworkkiller]

..though I guess it will probably save him from being raped in prison.

Idk, I guess some of those lifers think they got nothing to lose

[AntiBlitz]

Oh, but that would be inhumane 

You know, I would be all for castration for a rape conviction, except I have seen too often where a woman claims rape because she didn't want to get in trouble herself with a husband or boyfriend she cheated on, or parents found out, or she wants to hide behind her heavy drinking that led to her consenting, etc.

I wanna say it was Russia that i read was sterilizing sex offenders before reintegrating them into society, though im not sure, as this was a controversy almost a year or 2 ago.



EDIT: yep was right in 2011 Russia approved chemical castration by injecting sex offenders with a drug which would sterilize them as well as lower their sex drives

"In October 2011, Russia parliament approved a law that allows a court-requested forensic psychiatrist to prescribe the chemical castration of convicted sex offenders who have attacked children under the age of 14."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_castration