1) i asked arrowaine if it was a bug or a stupid mistake and he told me he tried to QML one of his guys. If he could have proved it was a bug then we prob could have worked out something more fair
2) we didnt lose any gear when we lost 1600 troops to an actual bug on the same castle, although they did offer to give us anything we lost back
3) we gave them their raw troops that they had left and gear for a shiny army (albeit not as shiny as it could have been)
4) we let all 5-10 guys most of which were unarmed and naked run away to shariz after the battle so the only thing they lost was the castle itself and some gear, which we have given them enough of already
Also, i for one am tired of fighting in that castle, we did the same strategy for like 5 straight battles now and it gets pretty repetitive after awhile. we shall continue the war on a different venue, or we welcome any attempt to take it back.