Just played Big Sable Lighthouse which was the only one I didn't play yet, so I feel I can properly vote now. Big Sable Lighthouse actually gets one of my votes, the map has a unique look to it, is fairly focused and provides a good balance of melee/cav/ranged friendliness.
Maps are all of good quality and it is hard to make a battle map that is particularly outstanding, but my second vote goes to Face Off. I played it once and it actually worked very well. It's has a gimmick to the gameplay which adds some flavour to the battle experience, I definitely feel like it deserves more than the one vote it has gotten so far. I find it a shame that Jarold chose to not submit some of his other maps, because I don't think Snowy Town is his best.
Also, a lot of people seem to not vote twice.
Poll