Give us 1h Crushthrough weapon/s

[Tyr_]

There is no use for 1h having crush through because the chance is partly based on the weight of the weapon. I just have a guess that the crush through chance of the warhammer (2.5 weight) gets close to 0% considering that my overheads get blocked by 1h swords from time to time when i use mallet (6weight, 24 str build). Rather add a knockdown for spear/warspear sideswing!

[Idzo]

True story.


Weapon rack and stone spamming 

[Bulzur]

-1 for fail troll.

[Jarlek]

This would be awesome in Strategus siege, to hurl big rock down at opponents.

And sieges

"They are hugging our walls so our archers and crossbowmen can't reach them!" -some dude.

"I got this shit!" -badass with a huge rock.

[Teeth]

probably along with the fact it would do pierce damage AND crushthrough).

Which is a lot worse than blunt, knockdown AND crushthrough, so no.

I really hate not having a crushthrough weapon for my class, can't I use a great maul with 1h wpf with some penalty or something? Luckily though, the great maul is so OP that its still viable without wpf.

[Zlisch_The_Butcher]

And I'd say NO is my opinion.  Being able to block with a shield, and then crush through when you swing would be OP.  I believe that's partially why the morningstar had crushthrough removed (probably along with the fact it would do pierce damage AND crushthrough).

Dude, ever tried the morningstar with a shield? It just so happens to be the slowest damn weapon ingame and not even deal good damage...
IMO give it crush through in 1h mode, it's balance for it, really, so slow even a Gmaul could spam it...
EDIT: -1 for being a shitposter.

[Kelugarn]

If any 1h weapon got crush through, it would have to be as slow as, if not slower, than the pike. Taking something with 6+ weight (so 6kg?) and trying to swing that weight on the end of a stick would make it more likely to dislocate your shoulder if you hit someone versus crushing through their guard.

[Tore]

THROWING PIKES

[Malaclypse]

I say yes, sure, with the added crux: any 1-handed weapon with crushthrough would of course be unbalanced, and would NOT be able to be used with a shield. It would have to have that crux to be anywhere close to balanced. I don't see any reason to not add a crushthrough weapon for the 1-hand classes bearing this stipulation in mind. Polearms have 1, two-hands have 3.

[oprah_winfrey]

Dude, ever tried the morningstar with a shield? It just so happens to be the slowest damn weapon ingame and not even deal good damage...
IMO give it crush through in 1h mode, it's balance for it, really, so slow even a Gmaul could spam it...
EDIT: -1 for being a shitposter.

Morningstar+shield+horse...please do not givd it crushthough in one hand mode...

[IR_Kuoin]

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Kelugarn]

....

Not sure which way you're going with this...