These threads are really stupid by definition but let's indulge I guess... but for the NA side to be accurate I think we'd have to break it down regionally. We've so much landmass over here separating many good players far far apart. And then you have to consider what CLASS they play ingame.
For example (NA), Rohypnol is by far the best HXbow, and a top player with everything else, and by KDR is objectively the best player in the game by that measuring stick. But I'd beat him in a 2h/polearm foot duel (not saying as an insult, I'm not bad.)
But for 1h, ManofWar and Cyranule are the best. Mano being East coast, Cyranule being west coast.
Are all three of those players really good and top of their game? Yep.
If all three did a lancing battle, rohy would win.
If all three did a 1h battle, well let's just say rohy would lose, and mano vs cyranule is fun to watch.
If all three did a Throwing battle (lol) Rohy would win.
It depends on the class and all this stupid stuff, there are lots of good players to acknowledge in this game, and no stupid list other than pressing TAB in game and looking at the scoreboard is going to give a better representation.