Well me and Phyrex did a little more testing with a kick slash yesterday, it seems for the 2h at least landing the slash (with a right swing) before the person could block was immensely difficult to time (even with his 15/27 build). Hiltslashing was never really an issue, actually what was is the lack of good footwork it required. The "fix" you have applied has not just nerfed the hiltslash, it has broken a lot of unintended tactics (like the aforementioned kickslash). I do want the hiltslashing to be harder, just the fix you applied is wrong, I would recommend a revert so you can a apply a fix which doesn't effect the entire class.