As soon as ladders get removed from battle I will love village maps. Mostly a good balance of cover, cav room, archer spots. Roofcamping gives archers too much archer spots.
There are tons of maps that have been created in the past, a lot of them seem to somehow dissappeared over time. Map rotation makers should ask information at the other continent servers and at unofficial servers. They probably have some different maps, implement them all.
Let QMD'ing and QMU'ing decide which ones have to stay. But voting information should responded too quickly. If a handful of maps get implemented, take a look at the votes the next day and get them out if people think they are shit. Use us to test maps, we can vote now.
In a few days I'll have 2 weeks of freedom, time to get myself into mapmaking. If I succeed in making something like a map at all, it will be a nice openish map without roofs!