Bay and Waning Cold can fuck right off. Iron Mine and Rivendell are both pretty lame imo. Silent Sea is nostalgic but not that fun really. Two Rivers is a map archetype (2 teams run straight at each other) that is better represented by other maps, and it's not all that fun fighting on that windmill hill every single time. Based on the overhead view I'm not sure which map Swamp is, but due to the amount of water on it I can only assume it plays similarly to Waning Cold in which case it too can get outa here.
We also seem to have a lot of random plains maps in rotation nowadays (not sure if any of them are named here, since plenty look like rather empty plains at least from the pictures), and some of them are better than others but I've got no idea which is which. If there's a way we could tone down the number of super open maps, that'd be good.
*NOTE: If someone who knows how to edit maps simply wants to remove all the water from Waning Cold (and maybe Swamp as well) I'm sure it'd make a great map. Really the presence of water deep enough to significantly slow you down is all that hinders it from being an otherwise fun village skirmish.