1/3 rule

[Chris_the_Animal]

This should not be possible:
http://c-rpg.net/index.php?page=strategusbattlesupcoming#!?page=strategusinfobattledetail&id=1210

A guy with 100 troops attacks a City with 2k Population and 800 Army. If the 1/3 rule would be implemented correctly, this guy should not be able to attack anyone with 301 and more troops.

[ARN_]

This should not be possible:
http://c-rpg.net/index.php?page=strategusbattlesupcoming#!?page=strategusinfobattledetail&id=1210

A guy with 100 troops attacks a City with 2k Population and 800 Army. If the 1/3 rule would be implemented correctly, this guy should not be able to attack anyone with 301 and more troops.

Well he must have attacked before they put in those 800 men, so I guess there is no problem here. You can attack with a fief with no army in it with only 1 troops if you'd like that but if they reinforce it shouldn't cancel the battle. It has to be like this so you are able to raid fiefs without strong enough army inside it

[Chris_the_Animal]

Well he must have attacked before they put in those 800 men, so I guess there is no problem here. You can attack with a fief with no army in it with only 1 troops if you'd like that but if they reinforce it shouldn't cancel the battle. It has to be like this so you are able to raid fiefs without strong enough army inside it

Could be, but still it is a Siege of 100 vs 2k...

[CrazyCracka420]

Could be, but still it is a Siege of 100 vs 2k...

Pretty sure it's that way because if you raid a fief it only fights the army garrison, so if you have no garrison, the attacker is going to get all your items in the fief (and I'm pretty sure gold too).

[Switchtense]

Totally possible.

When the assault was launched the city had no army at all. 0 Troops, only 2000 population.
Afterwards they plonked 800 troops in so when attacking the 1/3 rule was still met.

[Harpag]

From what I remember 1/3 rule not working above 1,8k so 601 troops can attack everything, even 100k garrison or mighty Praven, but what about population? Can we attack 0,5k pop village without garrison by single ticket or 2k pop city by 100 shepherds? Without AK 47 should be impossible 

[Noodlenrice]

From what I remember 1/3 rule not working above 1,8k so 601 troops can attack everything, even 100k garrison or mighty Praven, but what about population? Can we attack 0,5k pop village without garrison by single ticket or 2k pop city by 100 shepherds? Without AK 47 should be impossible 

unless he city has like no gear and are like pitchfork crazed peasants when the attackers have plate