Serious 2h weapon discussion (featuring blunt; Goedendag)

[Teeth]

infinite knockdown-kick-knockdown-hit-... combo.

This made me cry myself to sleep once after duelling wayne for some time. The 95 speed with that length and the strong tendency to knockdown means that the goedendag is an extremely potent weapon for that price. It is also hilarious to use with a shield. 117 length 1h rightswing with knockdown, aww yeah.

[Shaksie]

It is ridiculously weak though and with a shield it is almost as slow as a throwing hammer in mid air.

[Kafein]

It is ridiculously weak though

no

[BADPLAYER_old2]

To show that a high tier blunt weapon is not overpowered; despite the fact that Poleaxes blunt damage is their secondary mode, it is still very effective.

The alt mode is OP and I think anyone who uses one would agree, 32blunt 90speed 140length knockdown and shieldbreaking on the other side? Yeah that is a pretty ridiculous weapon.

(I use a +3 poleaxe)

[Angantyr]

Goedendag is a really good weapon that could easily cost more; for its price it's excellent.

[Shaksie]

no

Versus the 28b from a Mace and 29b from Studded Warclub and 32b from Poleaxe, yes it is.

[Kafein]

Versus the 28b from a Mace and 29b from Studded Warclub and 32b from Poleaxe, yes it is.

The mace is way too short. The studded warclub has a crappy thrust and the poleaxe is the objectification of overpoweredness on earth right now anyway. If you really want to start comparing weapons to the poleaxe, you can conclude that everything needs a buff.

[Shaksie]

The mace is way too short. The studded warclub has a crappy thrust and the poleaxe is the objectification of overpoweredness on earth right now anyway. If you really want to start comparing weapons to the poleaxe, you can conclude that everything needs a buff.

Read what I said you twat.
I said it is weak.
I have said there could be high tier blunt weapons.
Take your arguments elsewhere if you aren't going to address the relevent topics.

[Kafein]

Read what I said you twat.
I said it is weak.
I have said there could be high tier blunt weapons.
Take your arguments elsewhere if you aren't going to address the relevent topics.

You are the one wanting to discuss only damage then proceeds to call a weapon that has everything else than damage "weak".

You are being irrelevant, not I.

[Tindel]

Remove the knockdown,  then you cant get a damage buff.

Or make it unbalanced and reduce the speed,  then you can get a damage buff.


You see, that blunt damage may look low to yoiu, but against high armor it hits as hard as most greatswords, and it has knockdown.

[WITCHCRAFT]

The goadendag is the 2h version of staff/quarterstaff. Blunt knockdown, decent speed and reach, but bottom of the barrel damage and upkeep.

The poleaxes are top tier weapons, with cost to match. Despite their seemingly superior stats, you don't really see them much more often than any other weapon in battle and siege. They don't need a faster 2h counterpart.

Not really what the topic is about, but the studded warclub backs a little more oomph on side swings than the goadendag does. And it has knockdown and is balanced. Give it a try and yell HOME RUN every time you get a kill.

High tier blunt 2h exist, they are mauls. It's nice that they aren't stubby little clones of the polearms. I like that each weapon class has something unique to offer. You shouldn't "get it all" by investing your wpf into one thing.

[Shaksie]

Since noone is actually responding to the topic I'm going to lock this thread.

You are the one wanting to discuss only damage then proceeds to call a weapon that has everything else than damage "weak".

You are being irrelevant, not I.

Read the first post you cretin, for the last time I said that there are no 2h high tier non-cut weapons.