cRPG

cRPG => Suggestions Corner => Topic started by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 19, 2011, 02:37:16 pm

Title: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 19, 2011, 02:37:16 pm
Recurved Composite Bow : aka Ottoman - Turkish Bow..
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Recurved Composite Bow
weight 1.25
requirement 5
spd rtng 49
shoot speed 56
thrust damage 31 cut
accuracy 95

Gold: 14.490

  Hundreds of years ago, the mounted archers of Ottoman Turkey rode to battle with their famous composite bows made of horn, wood and sinew, proving unstoppable for armies of the Byzantine Empire and southern Europe. This powerful weapon of war later developed into the famous flight bow of phenomenal cast, equalled only by modern bows made of space age materials.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

The author explores the origin, the function and the performance of the bows, based on his many years' experience in making accurate replicas, on original sources and on his research on surviving original artifacts. Written for readers interested in the ancient technology, the book provides detailed instructions about manufacture and construction, including methods of decoration. It is not aimed at a casual reader or a beginning bowyer, but at experienced archers and craftsmen who are already familiar with the mechanics and the terminology. The Ottoman bows, renowned for great power and beautiful finish, are thought by many to be the pinnacle of perfection in the art of ancient bow making.

A video about Recurved Composite Bow:
http://www.onlinefootage.tv/video/show/id/6152 (http://www.onlinefootage.tv/video/show/id/6152)

The Ottoman fighting bow emerged in Europe from a long eastern tradition of using high velocity projectiles to hunt and fight on horseback. The author compares its performance (favourably) with the longbow and explains how the tactics employed with this singular artefact accounted for Ottoman success in battle.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Bows of composite construction, made of wood, horn and sinew, have been known in Asia for thousands of years. Among many other types, the Ottoman Turkish bow has attracted the most attention in the western world. According to Turkish sources (Yucel 1997), Tozkoparan Iskender and Bursali Suca in the early 1500s used this bow to achieve a range of 930 yards (1yd = 0.91m). In 1798, a record shot by Sultan Selim was recorded to a distance of 972yd (Klopsteg 2005). The Ottoman bows were the most important weapon of war, particularly for Turkish horse archers and remained the preferred weapon long after the introduction of firearms (Celebi 1991).

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Little information exists, however, about the effectiveness of Turkish bows in combat. Hansard wrote about the penetration of a metal helmet, made to withstand pistol shots, with two holes and the head (Hansard 1841). Shots through 2 inches (1in = 2.54cm) of metal, as well as through a 0.5 in plank at 100yd, have been recorded (Klopsteg 2005). A wooden mannequin clad in chain mail was completely penetrated (Ozveri pers. comm.). Data about the mechanical efficiency and performance of the bows have been published elsewhere (Karpowicz 2005). The purpose of this article is to assess the effectiveness of the weapon, through a consideration of the actual draw weight, i.e. the force required to pull the bowstring to the full length of an arrow. The results will allow a realistic assessment of the effective striking distance, together with the arrow's penetration. This in turn will help us to better understand the battle tactics of the Ottomans in conquering other countries during their period of expansion. The research on Turkish archery is also relevant to the use of bows in other areas of the world, either on a horse or on foot, and will help to shed light on the bow's effectiveness in warfare.

One of the last bowyer:
(click to show/hide)

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Construction and use

The Ottoman bow has several distinct sections: a centrally located grip of bulbous shape (kabza), two bending sections (sal) attached to the grip, two non-bending sections (kasan) with a ridge along the centre and two tip sections (bas) with notches for the bowstring (nocks). The bows represent the typical composite construction (Figure 1). A wooden core lamination runs through the entire bow. Horn strips are attached to the side of the bow facing the archer with the exception of the tips. A layer of sinew is attached to the opposite side up to the transition between the tips and the rigid sections. The horn-faced side is made round, the sinew-faced side is usually flat n the sal sections. Without the bowstring, the limbs have a pronounced reflex curvature. In a strung bow, only the bending sections are flexed. The rigid kasan sections retain their curvature, giving the bow the familiar 'Cupid' shape (Figures 2 and 3).

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

The archery collection of the Topkapi Palace Museum in Istanbul contains several hundred Turkish bows, dated from the fourteenth to the nineteenth centuries, as well as many bows of Persian, Crimean-Tartar and Arab origin. It is without doubt the largest collection of Ottoman archery equipment in the world (Yucel 1998). All the bows are very similar in appearance, with a maximum difference in length of about 25cm. Bows used by infantry were longer, other types, including war bows used on horseback (tirkes), target (puta) and flight bows (menzil) were of similar length (Yucel 1998). Generally, the length of bow was selected individually, depending on the archer's length of draw. Nevertheless, the war arrows' length varied from 25 to 29in, excluding the arrow point (Yucel 1998). The draw length of 28in was typical in archery shooting for distance, where a shorter, 24.5in arrow was drawn within a groove (siper) attached to the archers hand for an additional 3in. The 28in draw was chosen here as the most common length of draw.

A guy from talewords created this:
(click to show/hide)

What do you say my friends..First i will take your advice than create a poll if need be.. :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Dravic on March 19, 2011, 02:39:02 pm
Its almost Khergit bow. + AFAIK this bow was meant to be for Horse Archers, too. And remember, that 5 PD is highest PD wise horse archer can get.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 19, 2011, 02:44:16 pm
i changed pd ratio.. khergit bow and this has nothing in common maybe shape :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Joxer on March 19, 2011, 02:51:03 pm
This should be pretty much same or better as longbow. For historical accuracy of course.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: GMester on March 19, 2011, 10:47:28 pm
As a Hungarian my ancestors used the same type of bow, and i would be happy to have one myself.
I support this, the stats are fine for me, maybe accuracy same as longbow or better and the 5 pd is also good
 these bows needed some strenght to use, but because of crpg limitations (like the level cap and wpf cap) it is
impossible for a horse archer to go for pd6 or above if he wants to be accurate too.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Tears of Destiny on March 19, 2011, 11:34:08 pm
No, I see this as being a wee bit too unbalanced. There would be little point in getting a strongbow or warbow with this in shop. I also do not look forward to seeing horse archers use this, nor seeing what a triple heirloomed version can do. This might tip the balance of range too much.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Mullerian on March 19, 2011, 11:36:56 pm
No, I see this as being a wee bit too unbalanced. There would be little point in getting a strongbow or warbow with this in shop. I also do not look forward to seeing horse archers use this, nor seeing what a triple heirloomed version can do. This might tip the balance of range too much.

Im not entirely sure you are right, look at the speed rating. Its 1 better than the longbow which is pretty abysmal on the speed side. As for the bow itself, it seems like an improved version of the longbow with higer speed rating, higher shot speed, higher damage and lower requirement.

Edit: Id personally rather have the longbow buffed than add another bow that fills pretty much the same niche of slow and powerful.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Tears of Destiny on March 19, 2011, 11:40:35 pm
Having a requirement one less then the long bow and warbow means you can afford to have comparable/superior damage with significantly less str.

Already being 5 means you will have 3 more agil and thus 1 more weapon master. The higher damage means you effectively have a stronger PD for free as well, as any archer with PD 5 or 6 would have to be a lunatic to not use this for mid range shooting.

My main probem is that I do not see the point of using a warbow instead of this weapon, and that for PD 5 you can dominate mid-range shooting iby using this instead of the strongbow.

And honestly, eveyr horse archer will use this.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: sF_Zorro on March 20, 2011, 12:31:24 am
accepted with 26 cut
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 20, 2011, 12:56:55 am
Hmm lets make it 6 pd than.. it is obviously best bow for horse archers..but the set back is ..14k price.. the most expensive one.. maybe we can do this like 16k .. what do you say?
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Bobthehero on March 20, 2011, 01:07:29 am
You dont balance stuff with higher cost its already been mentionned many many many times.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Mullerian on March 20, 2011, 01:10:31 am
Hmm lets make it 6 pd than.. it is obviously best bow for horse archers..but the set back is ..14k price.. the most expensive one.. maybe we can do this like 16k .. what do you say?

Personally as an archer i havent really been limited by money, im halfway between 30 and 31 now and i made 90k this generation. So adding some to the price is really not balancing it, its just a "token" drawback.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: EliteDragon on March 20, 2011, 01:24:23 am
Make it have similar stats to the Khergit Bow but maybe it can have 1-2 more cut damage. This allows HA to have a weapon that they can at least battle ground archers with.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Siiem on March 20, 2011, 02:54:03 am
Make it have similar stats to the Khergit Bow but maybe it can have 1-2 more cut damage. This allows HA to have a weapon that they can at least battle ground archers with.

nah it should have the same stats as a khergit so that people pick it for the flavour.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Safavid on March 20, 2011, 04:37:54 am
Yes!  I have been waiting for this bow as a HA 5 Horse Archer.  I currently use the Khergit with Long Iron Mace (Persian/Ottoman).  If it could be like the Long Bow on horseback, I would love it with HA 5 stats.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: EliteDragon on March 20, 2011, 06:10:24 am
Yes!  I have been waiting for this bow as a HA 5 Horse Archer.  I currently use the Khergit with Long Iron Mace (Persian/Ottoman).  If it could be like the Long Bow on horseback, I would love it with HA 5 stats.

Exactly. That's what I'm hoping this could be. Basically a 5PD Bow specifically for HA.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 20, 2011, 07:03:53 pm
Recurved Composite Bow
weight 1.25
requirement 5
spd rtng 48
shoot speed 56
thrust damage 30 cut
accuracy 95

Gold: 15.890

OK now.. I read all the comments for this bow and worked on it a little more..i changed some of the stats and compared to top tier bows in the game..
PD requirement is 5.. THIS BOW IS FOR HORSE ARCHERS than for archers..(historically accurate and game balanced)
Speed Rating is 48..and it is the lowest firing rate bow in the game now with long bow..(game balanced)
Shoot speed is 56 .. if you watched the video and read the articles about this bow you will understand..It shoots arrows fastest in the game.
Dmg is optimal with Long bow
accuracy is 95..not good as warbow and strong bow
gold..the most expensive one like sniper xbow
Horse rider's bow..


War Bow
weight 1.5
requirement 6
spd rtng 59
shoot speed 51
thrust damage 27 cut
accuracy 96
Can't use on horseback

9,250 gold

Long Bow
weight 1.75
requirement 6
spd rtng 48
shoot speed 54
thrust damage 30 cut
accuracy 96
Can't use on horseback

8,312 gold

Strong Bow
weight 1.25
requirement 5
spd rtng 63
shoot speed 51
thrust damage 24 cut
accuracy 96

6,580 gold

New comments pls...
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Tears of Destiny on March 20, 2011, 07:07:57 pm
Honestly I am a lot more happy with it right now. I still need some time to think about it, but I do prefer this newer version a lot more.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 20, 2011, 07:12:35 pm
Honestly I am a lot more happy with it right now. I still need some time to think about it, but I do prefer this newer version a lot more.
In past posts i saw your point of view and thought about it.. i put this informations on my table and tried to simulate in my mind.. so at this point everybow has its place more or less.. need more ideas to fully balance it without losing its originality :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: BattalGazi on March 21, 2011, 06:46:22 pm
Money is not important, I want this baby :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: GMester on March 22, 2011, 01:27:55 pm
This new one is fine too, it will probably eat my wallet but i dont care :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Dexxtaa on March 22, 2011, 02:09:26 pm
Very well written description.

I'd vote yes simply for the presentation of the write-up alone =)

Otherwise, why not, I always wanted more ranged weapons to yell at over teamspeak anyway.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 23, 2011, 10:56:07 am
Poll added  :arrow:
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Magikarp on March 23, 2011, 11:05:21 am
Add it as a 2nd version of the strongbow, with exactly the same stats, I don't see why Horse Archers need a buff right now.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Rebelyell on March 24, 2011, 07:06:07 pm
weight 1.25
requirement 5
spd rtng 48
shoot speed 56
thrust damage 30 cut>>>>25<<<<<<< that no more in my opinion
accuracy 95


it is long bow , and you can use that on horse.....
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Mogu on March 24, 2011, 09:48:32 pm
This should be pretty much same or better as longbow. For historical accuracy of course.
Bad for game balance mind you.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Joxer on March 25, 2011, 09:59:40 pm
How's that then? Explain  :evil:
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: EponiCo on March 26, 2011, 02:33:05 am
+1 to Rebelyell
We don't need horse archers that kill you in 2 shots and ride away as soon as you look at them.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Tennenoth on March 26, 2011, 02:42:05 am
Also 48 speed would render it unusable like the longbow (release flaw). You need 50+ (I have found) to get rid of it but also for a PD5 bow, I think that the damage should be reduced to 25...

(I'm an archer myself, I don't think there is a need for a new bow although it would be nice to have the extra choice. Also I am waiting for the longbow to be buffered to a speed that doesn't bug the release! :))
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 26, 2011, 11:29:21 am
I read all the messages and try to answer them in my way..
This bow is an elite bow..It is the slowest but you will have a very good punch to anybody..also you can use this on horse.. if you are an infantry than you can choose a warbow-long bow or rec. comp. bow to your choice..if you are a cavalry you will go for fast but mid punching khergit bow or slow but good punching rec. comp. bow..

After all you need some serious prequisites to use this weapon..

-High level

-Skills

-Experience of horse archery or infantry archery

-Lots of gold..( Horse + Armor + rec. comp. bow + melee w + arrows) the upkeep will surely suck your blood..which means you wont be able to use rec. comp. bow for a very long time period - if you are not so rich .


1h Melee combatants have their SIDE SWORD..

Cavs have their HEAVY HORSES and LANCES

2h Melee combatants have their GREAT GERMAN SWORD

Polearm guys have their... fuck they have everything..!

Arhcers have their strong bow but not enough..

Mounted archers will have their time now.. RECURVED COMPOSITE BOW!!

pls try to synergy and dont be an ethnocentric bastard for eastern staff..

thank you guys :)
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Armbrust_Schtze on March 26, 2011, 12:08:31 pm
there IS a composite bow alread! ffs dump threats -,-
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Marshal_Nemesis on March 29, 2011, 09:27:46 pm
up..
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Sean_Drew on March 29, 2011, 09:50:25 pm
I said no.

This Bow would be totally strange.

More damage like a war bow ? ( which should have most damage even over long bow by the way , cause war bows have much more pounds to pull , than long bow in real )  Funny.

Shoot speed is too slow for such a bow , you would like to see.

Requirement too high ...

The only thing ok on your bow is accuracy.

But simply take the Khergit Bow. This is the bow on the pictures ( like hungarian or mongol bow ) .

If you think about the firerate of bows 31 were too high.

By the way i think that war bow should make most damage. Maybe 31 too , but much less accuracy. The warbow ingame is totally unrealistic. If you see how difficult it is to pull a real warbow , you would understand , that a bow with 120 pounds pullpower can not be shot like a "sniper-bow" , which it is ingame.

Maybe put in a Warbow with 35 cut damage , but 80 accuracy. That would be more realistic.

But your Bow .... simply take the Khergit.
Title: Re: New Bow: Recurved Composite Bow
Post by: Murchad on March 29, 2011, 10:16:16 pm
The strong bow is modeled after the turkish style of composite bow.
this thread seems dumb.
If someone models a more detailed bow go ahead and add it as an alt to the strong bow, same stats
this game was made by the turks im sure they had their bow in mind when they modeled the strong bow.

btw i'm really into archery and shoot a hungarian grozer made turkish stye recurve.