Buffed Characters

[Ronin]

In short:
Buffing everyone without changing the current balance, or whatever the devs change it to be.

The reason:

(click to show/hide)

I know you all will not like this idea. But I think cRPG is really boring. You try to build up a character that can have only one mastery which is equal in quality to it's counterpart in the native multiplayer. The point is we can already play this character without spenting time in native multiplayer. In addition, in native our gameplay has more variety due to the character we play in native multiplayer has different proficiencies and masteries. As infantry for example, you can use a proper shield + one handed sword + throwing javelins + two handed weapon whenever they are needed and suit well to the recent situıation. In short terms, individual strategy includes more diversity. However in cRPG you can only have 1 or 2 proficiencies which you spent hours to achieve. Yet somewhat useless, compared to native. Of course there is a balance in cRPG, because everyone is weaker. But Native is also balanced (still far more balanced from what I've seen compared to cRPG) with useful characters.
The tick is:
cRPG is claimed to be a RPG and RPG means leveling up in those days. leveling up to be a fantasticly powerful character. Yet cRPG does not gives this taste to the player, but for a no lifer that has 18 heirloomed items and +30 above level. And I am not a no lifer. I play games to have fun and enjoy my time not only for levelling up my character and leveling up to nothing.

Some of your possible answer:

(click to show/hide)

If you don't like cRPG then piss off.

My answer to their answer:

(click to show/hide)

You are a donkey.

[Vibe]

Close the door on your way out 

[Gheritarish le Loki]

I guess you are new to cRPG, back in the days there was no lvl cap, and ppl could level to 40+, wpf was gain in a higher rate, meaning you could have 200+wpf or be almost good in every weapons, not slot system meaning you can grab all the stuff you want like a swiss knife.
Well the mod was pretty enjoyable to veteran, pwning the fuckin´peasant all over the time.
In fact it becomes quickly lame, u.realistic and broke game mechanics (lighning fast strike, arrows release before end of animation). It becomes unplayable for new and casual players.

chadz always said that he didn´t want his mod to be a wow warband, grinding and leveling is not the final goal of cRPG.
I see many difference with native, first his customization, you can do almost everything and what you want, but for sure you have to male choice, you can´t be good in everything, you can be hybrid but you will have to be average or with average gears.

[Ronin]

@Vibe
Very creative
I am trying to share my thoughts in here. If you (this you refers to forum users) have a constructive comment don't beware. Even if it is an opposite argument I would be glad to hear.

@gheritarish
Hmm yes actually I am quite new to this mod. Well I have not seen those days and they do not really sound good. But compared to the recent version it sounds somewhat better. Instead of slow motion I prefer fast motion. It would be more fun and more challenging to the experienced players to block fast swings and avoiding arrows. It sound more anime-like.

[Tears of Destiny]

@Vibe
Very creative
I am trying to share my thoughts in here. If you (this you refers to forum users) have a constructive comment don't beware. Even if it is an opposite argument I would be glad to hear.

@gheritarish
Hmm yes actually I am quite new to this mod. Well I have not seen those days and they do not really sound good. But compared to the recent version it sounds somewhat better. Instead of slow motion I prefer fast motion. It would be more fun and more challenging to the experienced players to block fast swings and avoiding arrows. It sound more anime-like.

No to the bolded part.

As the the original post. Jack-of-all trade characters do not appeal to me, for we might as well play native if people can branch out into innumerable roles.

I like that under the current system a character has to be built to perform only a handful of roles, thus making abttlefield specialization more special, and rewarding teamwork and eliminating the "rambo" syndrom. It also helps make characters more unique.

With cRPG, leveling up and reaching level 30 or beyond does turn you into a "powerful" character when looking within the game itself and compared to other cRPG characters. I am also fine with this.

I also disagree that battles are too slow. We still end up far more often then not with 100 players gloriously slaughtering one another in under five minutes at least on the NA servers. Also given the average skill level in cRPG I don't think we need more of a "challenge" for players to dodge arrows considering the average amount of fail I see in that department... -_- As for the melee part of being more challenging with faster combat speeds, again people seem to be challenged just fine with the current speeds.

Faster looks cool, but in practice I am just not a fan of it for Mount and Blade. We already have epic duels as well as quick dirty fights with the current system. We also already have a rampant amount of "one-shotting" going around so I don't think people need much of a buff considering it is already possible to make a character who chops down everyone in one or two swings (unlike native).

[chadz]

One of the differences between cRPG and other/real MMOs is that you are not born a hero, you have to earn it. Grinding will not make you perfect or impenetrable - if you, as a player, don't have the skill to use your character, it's pretty useless. This means you need high player skills to be a hero, and not everyone will become one, and that is good.

It is somewhat true that at first glance the character development results in something similar to native. But if you have a closer look, you will see all the fine nuances in the character development. Everyone has preferences, his own skill magix, etc etc.

cRPG is not, and should never be, about playing longer to get an advantage. It's 80% player skill and 20% char skill, and I think we like it that way. There are enough alternatives where it's the otherway around

edit:

cRPG is claimed to be a RPG and RPG means leveling up in those days. leveling up to be a fantasticly powerful character.

I think we disagree on the definition

RPG means RolePlayingGame. When I started playing that didn't mean leveling, it meant you play as a different character. I am sorry if that confused you

[Son Of Odin]

+1 for chadz, but give us the santa hat back! We need it for our santa subclan, it has serious rp approach behind it and we need the hat for it to be complete .

[Gheritarish le Loki]

Yeah it´s sad that for commercial reason the gaming producer have turn rpg into leveling/grinding game (something like wow).

I guess it´s why many of us prefer playing indie games, to found the spirit of old games where fun and discovery were first over great design and uber power character.

[Berserkadin]

The tick is:
cRPG is claimed to be a RPG and RPG means leveling up in those days. leveling up to be a fantasticly powerful character. Yet cRPG does not gives this taste to the player, but for a no lifer that has 18 heirloomed items and +30 above level. And I am not a no lifer. I play games to have fun and enjoy my time not only for levelling up my character and leveling up to nothing.[/spoiler]

Fucking fail

[Ronin]

cRPG is not, and should never be, about playing longer to get an advantage. It's 80% player skill and 20% char skill, and I think we like it that way. There are enough alternatives where it's the otherway around

edit:
I think we disagree on the definition

RPG means RolePlayingGame. When I started playing that didn't mean leveling, it meant you play as a different character. I am sorry if that confused you

Aah you got me wrong. I did not mean that. I meant definition of RPG is expanded. By "Role playing", I meant something similiar to what reasonable people do in PWmod; and by RPG i meant something similiar to what every people do in cRPG mod. In cRPG mod the only thing people focus is to killing enemy and leveling up during the process. That is a type of RPG, not role playing; according to the gaming industry.
Of course there may be some people who are trying to Role play. But I have never seen a one yet.

Edit:
Ehm... and I must add something. I am playing as an archer in the cRPG, at least I was (before got bored). And despite my level 30 character, my character is still far more useless than it's Native counterparts. In native I can shoot accurately from a veeery distant target with ease, but in cRPG I can't. Plus a heavily armored guy takes 4-5 shoots to kill if you're not using a long bow and Long bow is incredibly slow. You both have to shoot from close distance and have to decide: slow but effective shoots or fast but unefficient shoots, or maybe something between those.
Of course those limitations are needed to provide the balance. I can not imagine how long people would whine because of archers if it would be powerful as I want. But it is not fun playing as a skilless archer, which leads to a boring game. My time is wasting under a time labeled "woohoo I'm getting xp when playing yeeehoooaaaa". All is a deception. If the game deflects it purpose away from having good time to getting xp it becomes something else. That's all I've got to say.

[Dehitay]

Edit:
Ehm... and I must add something. I am playing as an archer in the cRPG, at least I was (before got bored). And despite my level 30 character, my character is still far more useless than it's Native counterparts. In native I can shoot accurately from a veeery distant target with ease, but in cRPG I can't. Plus a heavily armored guy takes 4-5 shoots to kill if you're not using a long bow and Long bow is incredibly slow. You both have to shoot from close distance and have to decide: slow but effective shoots or fast but unefficient shoots, or maybe something between those.
Of course those limitations are needed to provide the balance. I can not imagine how long people would whine because of archers if it would be powerful as I want. But it is not fun playing as a skilless archer, which leads to a boring game. My time is wasting under a time labeled "woohoo I'm getting xp when playing yeeehoooaaaa". All is a deception. If the game deflects it purpose away from having good time to getting xp it becomes something else. That's all I've got to say.

We constantly get people who come from the same point of view as you. And it's almost always because they haven't played this game in its optimum way. This is a team game. You really need to join a clan or some kind of group and play using strategies rather than just personal skill to get the most out of it. People get confused cause personal skill can be so powerful on its own, but that's not the true goal of this game. If you've ever gone on battle and seen one team scatter out and try to take out whatever's convenient for each individual person, and the other team just move around in a massive mob, it becomes obvious which tactic is superior very quickly.

[Myltinous]

As a newb to the game. I prefer the current system because, while you may not be as good, it adds realism that many games lack. It feels great to play a game where you feel human while playing. I may not be that skilled but I know it's not because the other guy has grinded for so long that his char OP, but that he beats me because he has more skill because he played the game longer. It fills me with satisfaction to see my guy one-shotted in the face because I know that someone would die from that. 

@ Ronin: If you aren't satisfied with being an archer, then I would suggest going with a crossbowmen. Yes, they take forever to load, but they allow you to take your time to get accurate shots off. They don't need any skill besides strength to use them too so you can mix it with a 1h shield or 2h build. Hope you find a way to enjoy this mod 

[Gnjus]

In native I can shoot accurately from a veeery distant target with ease, but in cRPG I can't.

In the old days it was piece of cake, now that they "balanced" the archery it's.....still doable.

[Tristan]

I agree with Tears and chadz completely.

And finally it needs to be underlined that cRPG is not primarily about levelling your character but your own skill.
I have been playing for almost a year of warband (some 850 hours) around 9 months of cRPG. I can hardly call myself average but that is because I'm a sucker at action games.

What people need to understand is that when Georges run around with his spamberge and plate, it is not the equipment doing the kills. We see lots of failed clones. The guy (strange as it may be) actually knows how to play. I use him becuase he is a good example. New players think that they can go to level 30 buy the expensive equipment and start chopping the enemy. That is not the case.

Jorm and Bifi from my clan make more kills at lvl 23 that I do at 30 (almost...). They know how to block 95% of the attacks... I get 65% on a good day. I make a decent faint every fourth time, they make it every other. I chamber by luck, they do it on purpose.
When you start to realize this, you will find it far more fun to level your own s(kill) and not your characters.

Tristan over'n'out.

[Kenji]

cRPG is claimed to be a RPG and RPG means leveling up in those days.

This line baffles me. Please don't generalize one genre with personal views.

RPG = Role Playing Game

See the word Role Playing? That is what mattered even more to me, besides, personal skills > levels > equipments.