Going to post this here so I have all of my thoughts in order for my next build.
Level 36
Level: 36
Strength: 18
Agility: 27
Skill to attr: 8
Hp: 53
Ironflesh: 0
Power Strike: 6
Athletics: 9
Shield: 5
Weapon Master: 9
One Handed: 185
The goal is to use heavier body armor around the 17-20 weight range, ~68+ armor, heavy gauntlets, and a good helmet/decent boots. I will move like an 8 ath build with ~15 weight body armor (without shield, ~10-12 with), or a 7ath build with ~7 weight body armor no shield. I will move fast enough to be quick in melee, and the armor will help produce weaker blows from negative speed bonus. Low PS is offset by the high amounts of wpf, making me similar in power to a 7 PS user, as well as the use of a blunt weapon sidearm against heavy armor users where I will have a huge speed advantage. Less health is offset by higher armor where I would still be able to dodge strikes and better manipulate speed bonus. 5 points in shield would be more useful than 5 points in IF to help block arrows/bolts.
A point in weapon speed is ~12 pure wpf, around ~15 to account for the extra % loss from armor, so I will generally swing with +3 speed compared to the average player, swinging the 97 speed maces as though they were 100 speed.
Each point in PS is ~+2 damage of the weapon type. Using a slower, more powerful weapon, I will still swing quickly, similar in damage to a higher PS build using a shorter, quicker weapon, but my character will be much faster. Therefore, the grosse messer (37 cut), dao weapons, or a 100 length cut 1h (34-35 cut) weapon with a mace for a sidearm is the ideal set.
Largest weaknesses:
Cav
Headshots from arrows
Bolts
Blunt+Pierce weapons
Shields help against all of those except cav, since those weapons aren't very good against shields. High athletics helps against blunt+pierce weapon users that struggle to get a proper hit. A hoplite sidearm can be used with 1wpf to defend against cav for those kinds of maps.
In strat, the 18 strength allows me to wear the heaviest armor if need be, and I will be much faster than mostly any opponent I face.