I didn't knew about voice acting and writing (and I don't care that much anyway), but my main point of contention with what other people said about the game was the graphics that were supposedly impressive even though in my opinion they aren't. He did not comment on whether the game is fun for more than a few hours so he kind of avoided one of my main concerns for a 50$ game which seems a priori quite repetitive (like many games with emergent content).
He says several times that the game looks very good but he doesn't understand where the high VRAM comes from.
And he says that it is very fun IF you do like the Batman combat mechanics. That's what the game is about: Killing Orcs in a stylish and cool manner.
The game looks very nice and gives a good atmosphere. Most importantly for me, it is very polished. Even TB says the the QA made a very good job on this one.
If you think about getting it, make up your mind about the combat really. It boils down to that. When you're like me and love the Batman combat, then you gonna enjoy this game very much. If the combat mechanics don't excite you that much, wait for a discount/sale - it's worth playing in any case cuz that Nemesis system is really really cool.
Imagine GTA 6 having such a system for Cartell Bosses