xant, you are leaving the physiological and biomechanical aspects out of your argumentation, and seem to be doing just what you are accusing others of: repeating what you have read.
depending on the training level and the kind of food you are talking about, your warrior diet is ok, and follows basic aspects of any scientifically supported diet, its highly unpractical for a fat man to try it however.
also no rules: getting in your calories the way you are atm, is a good way to get yourself a nice heap of typ 2 diabetes :/