Arys, FrugFrug and Farmer Nate for my money because they go all out with the low end crap, none of this "I'm wearing rags but look at my massive great sword" business.
Then I'd go Eye Beat for his peasant look that he use to rock.
FINALLY!
BigBird for his couple of gens of scythe wielding infuriation. He seemed to be able to nail pretty much anyone with any weapon and then I started using an MW scythe and cleaning up it was proven beyond all doubt, truly a great player.