Shielder, with hybrid archery and/or riding at times.
Why? A few reasons: I do not like manual blocking (it requires time to do and get used to it, and there are extended periods of time when I cannot play and forget most of it), and it allows me to push, hold positions and pull back, fight against a few opponents and come out alive, get off ranged reticules, etc. I have never wanted to be the star in the show, I would be happier being the man behind the curtains that gets everything going while not being appreciated.
Then, when I feel like my chopper is not enough, I decide to get a nerf gun by hybridising into archery. Totally not worth it (low damage, I cannot aim for shit), except for the look on someones face when I drop my bow, and defeat them with my tiny 1her and shield.
And sometimes, I feel like I really should give myself a disadvantage, I add riding and horse archery on top of that. Awful UP build, but fun one.