Right back when I first started playing really, I was getting to grips with my character (I had got it to a reasonable level and had all the equipment that I wanted). I got caught between Sawa, in his black plate etc and two randoms and of course, I'd run out of arrows (never been without my bow!
) and was fighting with my maul. I managed to club down one of the randomers before Sawa got within range, somehow, no idea how I did it, I blocked him and managed to hit him back, knocking him down. From there I hit him once more which amazingly killed him before collecting a crossbow bolt to the side of the skull.
In the dead chat, Replica said "lol well done Tennoth" which made me grin because I had a great amount of respect for the bloke.
To summarise, my proudest moment is;
1) Fleeing and getting trapped.
2) Exploiting a horrible weapon with knockdown & crush-through.
3) Killing two players in melee, albeit one being Sawa.
4) Dying to another crossbow headshot.
5) Being congratulated by someone who couldn't spell my name.
Nothing has really compared to that since though. My character has been through a lot of changes, refining and I've become a lot more skilled than I used to be and a lot of the charm of just killing off two people in panic (I had no idea what I was doing at the time) and generally just being some unknown pleb running around. Now I'm just a pleb.