And at this point I believe you should be reported. Please let the ADMINS make the decision and stay out of it. If you are not directly involved and have nothing to contribute, leave.
You have also ignored, what is, in effect a full explanation of this event. Take your "expert opinion" elsewhere and leave this up to the people who matter. Or are you chivalry or know him?
Reported for what? Providing a logical argument that can actually be substantiated? This is an emotional out lash. The original poster was not directly involved and again by that logic, this post should not even exist, nor should you be here as well.
The truth of the matter is, that you, nor OP, or anyone else has submitted any kind of logical or well written argument to refute or in the very least challenge the points that I have made.
If this goes through, it will only prove two things:
1) That bans are made irregardless of evidence, logic, or argumentation and players are at the emotional whim of their peers and the admins. No real 'justice' can be served under this system.
2) It also sets the tone that there is absolutely no precedence to who is allowed to speak or judge the information and is subject to the abuse that would occur if I was 'indeed' reported for critiquing and providing solid argument(s) to the situation, since I was indeed not involved.
Its important to reflect that no one currently posting in this thread was directly involved in the incident or a player who was team wounded.
Again by your own logic, you should be reported along with the op for not being 'directly involved'.
Stop your emotional out-lashes, you will gain no proper respect if you can not come to a logical conclusion or a solid argument without resorting to ad-hominem attacks and your emotional judgement of others.