cRPG

Off Topic => General Off Topic => Topic started by: Berserkadin on April 08, 2013, 09:47:57 pm

Title: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Berserkadin on April 08, 2013, 09:47:57 pm
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2013/apr/08/margaret-thatcher-dies-aged-87

To bad it took that old witch such a long time.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Weren on April 08, 2013, 10:02:29 pm
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Tennenoth on April 08, 2013, 10:16:36 pm
Interesting that people from other countries, who were unlikely to have lived during her stay in office find her to be in such a negative light.

She changed a lot of things and although she made mistakes (like believing that some of the populace wouldn't be against the poll tax which I believe in theory is more than reasonable, but that could just be because I've been indoctrinated by my Grandfather on that matter) as do all world leaders and indeed everyone from time to time.

Her time has passed and at least a little respect should be shown, even if you didn't like her or what she tried to do, I mean, she was the first female Prime Minister and I don't think that anyone can deny that was an achievement she should be remembered for.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: CrazyCracka420 on April 08, 2013, 10:40:14 pm
As someone who doesn't know much about her, the only things I could tell you off the top of my head was that she was hands off when it came to regulations in the financial industry, and the child poverty rate was ridiculous high under her reign.  Both are big negatives in my mind, but I don't agree with most conservative policies, unless it's keeping spending under control (mainly by prioritizing the most important things we need to spend on)
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 08, 2013, 10:41:26 pm
You either love her or you hate her.

But regardless she was prime minister for 11 years and in that time changed the face of the country. A very powerful figure, a patriot and she even indirectly revamped the labour party. It was pretty much because of her and the tory party dominance that new labour arose. Not to mention when she came to be prime minister there were an estimated 30 million days a year lost because of strike action, by the time she finished it was down to 2 million.

She certainly deserves some level of respect and it was sad that she suffered so much from dementia in her later years.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Kafein on April 08, 2013, 10:47:37 pm
With my limited knowledge, I think she led Britain to become one of the most important players in global finance. Even though now in retrospect that doesn't seem like such a good idea, I wish current day political leaders had as much courage and actually fix things. Hell, all countries in Europe today are sinking in loans, a new Tchatcher would be a blessing for the future.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Henry_Broodsonson on April 08, 2013, 11:52:12 pm
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Prpavi on April 09, 2013, 12:36:52 am
i think Joey Barton said all it needs to be said  :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen:

"I'd say RIP Maggie but it wouldn't be true. If Heaven exists that old witch won't be there..."
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Osiris on April 09, 2013, 10:34:35 am
Thatcher was one of the great PMs, Before her Britain's economy was in decline, we had 3 day weeks, 25% inflation and trade unions running the country. Privatisation of major companies forced them to become competitive or die, taxes were cut and people could buy council houses.

Love her or hate her seems to depend on whether you worked in mining and state run companies or not. She served Britain for 11 years so she cant have been that unpopular, The fact the labour party got into power and continued "thatcherism" and the fact Blair etc praise her says something.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing sure she made mistakes which leader doesn't, she did however change the face of Britain.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Tennenoth on April 09, 2013, 11:57:40 am
What hacks me off is the footage of people celebrating her death and burning pictures of her! She wasn't some military dictator oppressing you, the hell are you doing? She didn't even ransom your dog, she just ran the country, and as Osiris said, she can't have been that unpopular seeing as she was voted in again.

Also if the "Joey Barton" you're talking about is the footballer, then he would have been 8/9 when Maggie left office, what solid political views could he have possibly had? I'm sure he didn't know her personally. I was born in 1991, I have no political views on her first hand, they're from what my parents and their parents have said and my own research into what she did. I'm absolutely sure I didn't give a toss about politics until I was 17, looking to go to University when it suddenly meant that it would effect me, I mean, I knew Major, Blair, Gordon were "in power" throughout my life but I didn't care what they were doing.
To similarly put this, John Major was in power for the first 6 years of my life, all I know is that he was on Strictly & can't dance!

Anyway, what I am getting at here is it whether or not you liked her, a minimal level of respect surely is courtesy? I don't know how to phrase this without sounding arrogant, conceited or any other form of "thinking oneself better than others" but have a little respect. If someone I didn't like died, I wouldn't start fist pumping let alone burning pictures of them.

(click to show/hide)

I know it's a minority, I know what I am typing is specifically my, albeit strong opinions and I know I am technically in a well off position thanks to my family but I was always taught to show respect for the dead, unless they made their soul purpose in life to make others peoples a misery. She didn't go out of her way to screw people over, she might have "divided the nation" but that was nearly 23 years ago...
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 09, 2013, 12:01:46 pm
The one that cracked me up (saddened as well) was the picture of some 20 somethings spraying a bottle of champagne in celebration in Trafalgar Square. All I could think was:
1. You weren't alive/aware of her at the time.
2. You can afford to spray a bottle of champagne all over the place so she really can't have ruined your lives.
3. Fucking twats.

As for those pictures: Scots. That's all I can say (ok not all Scots).

It definitely is a minority though. They showed videos of some of the 'main' parties in public places and most of them had like 20 people and the occasional guy with a megaphone. It's just sad it's 'cool' to hate her amoung University aged people, particularly at lefty uni's and as a result that age bracket of between 20-30 seems to feel they know exactly what happened at the time and how ruined their lives are.

There are legitimate people who did have a hard time as a result of her policies, undoubtedly. But equally much of what she did can be considered necessary, and people have enjoyed a great deal of affluence in general since then, particularly as a result of service industry jobs, of which there are now millions in the UK and provide higher wages in general. I don't want to turn this to political but arguably many of the major complaints of recent years occurred as a result of labour administration, yet people still feel the need to blame their current troubles on an old figurehead. If people wanted things to be better they should take their head's out their arses and do something about it, not just whine and moan and above all, certainly don't disrespect someone who has died.

/rant
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Tennenoth on April 09, 2013, 12:07:52 pm
The one that cracked me up (saddened as well) was the picture of some 20 somethings spraying a bottle of champagne in celebration in Trafalgar Square. All I could think was:
1. You weren't alive/aware of her at the time.
2. You can afford to spray a bottle of champagne all over the place so she really can't have ruined your lives.
3. Fucking twats.

As for those pictures: Scots. That's all I can say.

It definitely is a minority though. They showed videos of some of the 'main' parties in public places and most of them had like 20 people and the occasional guy with a megaphone. It's just sad it's 'cool' to hate her amoung University aged people, particularly at lefty uni's and as a result that age bracket of between 20-30 seems to feel they know exactly what happened at the time and how ruined there lives are.

There are legitimate people who did have a hard time as a result of her policies, undoubtedly. But equally much of what she did can be considered necessary, and people have enjoyed a great deal of affluence in general since then, particularly as a result of service industry jobs, of which there are now millions in the UK and provide higher wages in general. I don't want to turn this to political but arguably many of the major complaints of recent years occurred as a result of labour administration, yet people still feel the need to blame their current troubles on an old figurehead. If people wanted things to be better they should take their head's out their arses and do something about it, not just whine and moan and above all, certainly don't disrespect someone who has died.

/rant

My post was doctored about twelve times before I released it, removing things such as "pictures from Scotland" since it really does make people think that everyone is like that. I'm 100% sure my Grandmother wouldn't have done that and she was a nurse so would have been quite close to the "student nurse uprising" over poll-tax.
As I say, it's a minority and not specific to one region but I agree wholeheartedly with number 3.

There you are! :D
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 09, 2013, 12:09:44 pm
My post was doctored about twelve times before I released it, removing things such as "pictures from Scotland" since it really does make people think that everyone is like that. I'm 100% sure my Grandmother wouldn't have done that and she was a nurse so would have been quite close to the "student nurse uprising" over poll-tax.
As I say, it's a minority and not specific to one region but I agree wholeheartedly with number 3.

Yeah I added more to my post about the minority thing.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 09, 2013, 12:19:13 pm
It doesn't really matter if you liked her or not. It's just a question of proper conduct really. Everyone deserves a basic amount of respect.

I am quite the old fart around here and I keep thinking this a lot of times: There is no more respect.

And it's not just about some internet forum that is rather low-priority. When I see young people on the street, it's the same thing. There is nothing left from "respect your elders" or anything similar. If you go around and ask people about their definition of respect, pride and honour, I am very sure that you won't get a proper answer.

I hold respect, pride and honour in a pretty high regard in my personal life. After all, there is not much else you have for yourself. If you say that out loud, you have to watch out that you won't end up in same Neo-chocolate chip cookie/Facist corner... but I digress...

You can think a lot of things but the only thing that matters is what you do. That's what people judge about you...
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 09, 2013, 12:23:55 pm
It doesn't really matter if you liked her or not. It's just a question of proper conduct really. Everyone deserves a basic amount of respect.

I am quite the old fart around here and I keep thinking this a lot of times: There is no more respect.

And it's not just about some internet forum that is rather low-priority. When I see young people on the street, it's the same thing. There is nothing left from "respect your elders" or anything similar. If you go around and ask people about their definition of respect, pride and honour, I am very sure that you won't get a proper answer.

I hold respect, pride and honour in a pretty high regard in my personal life. After all, there is not much else you have for yourself. If you say that out loud, you have to watch out that you won't end up in same Neo-chocolate chip cookie/Facist corner... but I digress...

You can think a lot of things but the only thing that matters is what you do. That's what people judge about you...

Should force all teenagers to watch Pride and Prejudice (BBC version) and demand they act like Mr Darcy, Mr Bingley and Jane/Elizabeth Bennet  :wink:
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Kafein on April 09, 2013, 12:29:30 pm
I had similar feelings the day we learned that Ben Laden had been killed. I thought, ten years later nobody would give a damn even in the USA. But how wrong I was. Parties all over the states for what was basically a symbolic victory at this stage. Kinda reminiscent of shoe throwing and flag burning in the Middle East whenever someone says something about Islam.

Also benkei, about the "no more respect" part, I can guarantee you it is you being an old fart. Your own elders had the exact same opinion of you, and their elders about them too and so on. All of that is perception.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Gnjus on April 09, 2013, 12:41:07 pm
If memory serves me well that "old witch" lifted economy of her country from the mud it fell into and quite successfully dealt with hooliganism. Those two things should be more then enough (even without her other achievements) to deserve some respect in the moment of her big jump to the other side of Styx river. Those useless teenage imbeciles know nothing about life and have no manners so I wouldn't pay any attention to them, same as the OP kurwa.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 09, 2013, 12:43:19 pm
[...]

Also benkei, about the "no more respect" part, I can guarantee you it is you being an old fart. Your own elders had the exact same opinion of you, and their elders about them too and so on. All of that is perception.
I hardly disagree. When I was 12, I stood up when some old lady stepped into the tram. You don't see this any more here. Neither were 17yrs old little boys guilty of beating up a 45yrs old father of 3 cuz he stood up for some little girls who were bullied by those wankers in the train. Beating up to the extent that he died after 2 weeks in intensive care.
I could give you a dozen of examples from where I am from. It's perception in a way, yea. People just don't give a shit. And that's exactly the problem.

I found my understanding of respect, pride and honour when I was something like 14/15 years old. It's a problem with the majority of a whole generation here. "Perception" is the lazy explanation.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Kafein on April 09, 2013, 01:04:07 pm
I hardly disagree. When I was 12, I stood up when some old lady stepped into the tram. You don't see this any more here.

What exactly tells you young people don't do that today ? Except a handful of examples you won't forget, in opposition with conter-examples you will forget ?

Neither were 17yrs old little boys guilty of beating up a 45yrs old father of 3 cuz he stood up for some little girls who were bullied by those wankers in the train. Beating up to the extent that he died after 2 weeks in intensive care.
I could give you a dozen of examples from where I am from. It's perception in a way, yea. People just don't give a shit. And that's exactly the problem.

Examples and perception again. Do you have statistics ?

I found my understanding of respect, pride and honour when I was something like 14/15 years old. It's a problem with the majority of a whole generation here. "Perception" is the lazy explanation.

You are not in their heads... To think that they are more evil than other young generations in their time to explain what you do not understand about them is the lazy explanation.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 09, 2013, 01:11:18 pm
I find you rather ignorant right now, Kafein.

Statistics of a big raise in youth alcohol abuse, teen pregnancies and higher rates of violent crimes back me up. If you wanna see them, look them up yourself. I know what I've read and seen and I can't be bothered to proof my point to you. Besides, I wrote clearly "where I come from". Afaik, we come from different places. Be happy if in your world they are respectful...

Let's agree to disagree otherwise.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: djavo on April 09, 2013, 01:18:11 pm
Ok just look at their intelligent faces and you will know everything.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Christo on April 09, 2013, 01:19:17 pm
I had a course called "thacherism and the cinema" last term in university. What we learned was that Britain under Thatcher was a police-state like country, were minorities like blacks, gays, people from Asia and so on were arrested and even beaten by policemen on a "regular" basis for no real reason.

Also, we learned that her government favored only the rich people, and gave a fuck about the working class. Also the fear that communists could infiltrate the country made them control many people and even arrest them for being affiliated with communists.

At least thats what I learned in that course about politics of Thatchers government. The course was about british cinema though, so this historical/politics stuff was not the main topic.

No wonder people from other countries have such a bad opinion about her and her government.

That's mostly right from what I remember reading about that regime.

That outlined part really left some borderline leftist/commie propaganda taste in my mouth though.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Kafein on April 09, 2013, 01:23:59 pm
I find you rather ignorant right now, Kafein.

Statistics of a big raise in youth alcohol abuse, teen pregnancies and higher rates of violent crimes back me up. If you wanna see them, look them up yourself. I know what I've read and seen and I can't be bothered to proof my point to you. Besides, I wrote clearly "where I come from". Afaik, we come from different places. Be happy if in your world they are respectful...

Let's agree to disagree otherwise.

You do have statistics. That's what I wanted to hear. I don't care about tears.

I had a course called "thacherism and the cinema" last term in university. What we learned was that Britain under Thatcher was a police-state like country, were minorities like blacks, gays, people from Asia and so on were arrested and even beaten by policemen on a "regular" basis for no real reason.

Also, we learned that her government favored only the rich people, and gave a fuck about the working class. Also the fear that communists could infiltrate the country made them control many people and even arrest them for being affiliated with communists.

At least thats what I learned in that course about politics of Thatchers government. The course was about british cinema though, so this historical/politics stuff was not the main topic.

No wonder people from other countries have such a bad opinion about her and her government.

I'm quite sure the police of that era wasn't very kind to anything not white brit, or at least a part of the policemen. But given the years it happened, I wonder how many writers weren't part of a communist group, and how many of those weren't manipulated or even directly funded by soviet secret services.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Osiris on April 09, 2013, 01:39:30 pm
I've noticed that trend from uni friends too, i don't understand where the hostility to differing views come from. Time will tell if its just the left or opposition that they enjoy :-P

Sadly some i know consider themselves superior because they went to uni even if they took pointless classes, human nature i guess

Ps sorry for poor grammar I'm on a tablet and its awkward as hell
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Christo on April 09, 2013, 01:40:00 pm
What is best to do in a situation like that is to "ascend".

Literally, get over them, above them mentally, then laugh at them going around in circles throwing shit at eachother like chimpanzees.

PS: Then realize that these easily manipulated herds of sheep decide about which group of cash hungry powermongers gets to lead your country.
Then you cry.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Osiris on April 09, 2013, 01:45:29 pm
I tend to lol and ignore some of them :-D ive known a guy since we started school, he was pro labour then pro tory and is now pro labour, basically anti whoever wins, i think he enjoys trying to be in the minority :-P
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 09, 2013, 01:47:29 pm
Yeah; I felt the same. Also, after 5 terms at university, I have the feeling that most of the profs and like ALL of the younger (aged 25-35) lecturers are mid/left - left - hardline-leftists. You never hear anyone of them leave a good word about conservative or mid/right minded people, politicians, political parties or government.
I even know some profs and lecturers who openly tell that they vote left - hardline-left and how they dislike people who vote mid/more right/conservative parties.

Not that I got a personal problem with that, as I am rather unpolitical, but I feel like being surrounded by "everything-that-is-not-left-or-even-more-left-is-shit-conservative-or-right-voting-people-are-imbeciles"-thinking people, and that kind of scares me, as I always thought a university is a place of objectivity and neutrality ...

And also, almost the same goes for most of the students who are my age or even a few years younger. "Uh you don´t vote left/your parents vote conservative? Get the fuck out of my face facist!".

I already found myself to feel really uncomfortable just because of this.

I went to Sussex University. Considered the most left wing University in the UK (Brighton yay) so I definitely got that feeling from my lecturers and the student body. Me and a few of my friends, all fairly conservative, used to find it incredibly amusing how they'd jump on every little injustice and blame the tory governement and inevitably protest about it. There are some things worth protesting about, but if you protest about everything you just look stupid and like you're there for the scene.

As for that course:
In fairness on the police front, that was probably left over from the 70's where the police were pretty notorious in this country, partly though because the criminal organisations were also notorious. Nothing really to do with Thatcher. The main criticism of Thatcher in relation to the police force is her reaction to the Hillsborough disaster.

As for the beating up minorities type stuff. I can only say I know countless people of ethnic origin who's families grew up during that time and never had a problem. Maybe the lecturer had seen to much This is England as the skinhead movement was around that time.

The communist thing I can understand being possible as many western countries had that occurring then.

Edit:

O and all those students are the ones who voted lib dem as well. So blame them for that.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Leesin on April 09, 2013, 03:32:27 pm
I don't love or hate her, but I do respect her, she stood by her guns, she did not tell lie after lie like many other politicians, she wasn't perfect and she did cause alot of bad things, but she also did alot of good. Funnily enough some guy I know wrote this list.

Things Margaret Thatcher DIDN'T Do:

1) Abandon the Falkland Islands to the Argies.
2) Cow Down to the IRA.
3) Allow 200,000+ Immigrants into the UK EVERY Year (It was between 13-50,000)
4) Institute the Human Rights Act, thus allowing murderous scum & terrorists to live here with no chance of kicking them out.
5) Roll over and allow Europe to dictate what we can and can't do.
6) Run up huge debts by spending money the Country didn't have and getting our credit rating reduced.

3, 4,5 and 6 have been done by other politicians since, I'm on the fence about 2 as it's not a simple subject. Well where 1 is concerned any of our leaders would be mad to abandon the Falklands to the Argies.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 09, 2013, 03:42:58 pm
I don't love or hate her, but I do respect her, she stood by her guns, she did not tell lie after lie like many other politicians, she wasn't perfect and she did cause alot of bad things, but she also did alot of good. Funnily enough some guy I know wrote this list.

Things Margaret Thatcher DIDN'T Do:

1) Abandon the Falkland Islands to the Argies.
2) Cow Down to the IRA.
3) Allow 200,000+ Immigrants into the UK EVERY Year (It was between 13-50,000)
4) Institute the Human Rights Act, thus allowing murderous scum & terrorists to live here with no chance of kicking them out.
5) Roll over and allow Europe to dictate what we can and can't do.
6) Run up huge debts by spending money the Country didn't have and getting our credit rating reduced.

3, 4,5 and 6 have been done by other politicians since, I'm on the fence about 2 as it's not a simple subject. Well where 1 is concerned any of our leaders would be mad to abandon the Falklands to the Argies.
Sounds like bar-room politics to me.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Casimir on April 09, 2013, 04:41:28 pm
An impressive career, although i disagree with the policies she enacted and the course she led society down.  Economic revitalisation and the expense of thousands of peoples jobs, homes and communities.  Its no surprise there was a lot of resentment to thatcher, i also don't think breeding 'new labour' is anything to be proud of.

Hindsight is of course 20:20, but tearing up the railways, closing the mines and the heavy industry in the UK were terrible decisions all made under her leadership.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Leesin on April 09, 2013, 04:51:30 pm
Sounds like bar-room politics to me.

Perhaps so, but for good reason, they are current political issues that really hit home with the average person, even those that are not much interested in politics. Take 3 for instance, at our current rate of immigration, combined with our native population reproducing, by 2020 Britain will be over populated, over population means higher unemployment rates, higher unemployment means more poverty, more poverty means more crime. Yet we sit back and let the EU dictate to us that we will let everyone in regardless, which points to number 5.

Number 4, Humans rights acts and the EU also, we have Abu Qatada, an extremist who we are being forced to house, feed and protect with our tax money because it would be "inhumane" to deport him to Jordan where he might face an "unfair trial" for his influence and plans in bomb attacks that were foiled. So our tax money is spent on this scumbag, ALOT of tax money, yet we have elderly people who can barely afford to live and keep their house warm. That is just one example of what pisses the average British person off.

Bar room politics perhaps, but it is bar room politics for a reason, they are the issues that really hit home with the average joe and have been going on for far too long.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Casimir on April 09, 2013, 05:07:47 pm
(conveniently ignore the many legitimate immigrants that move to the UK and work for a pittance doing jobs which are vacant because people would rather live on the dole)
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Leesin on April 09, 2013, 05:13:28 pm
(conveniently ignore the many legitimate immigrants that move to the UK and work for a pittance doing jobs which are vacant because people would rather live on the dole)


I have nothing against the immigrants that come here to work, and that is irrelevant to what i am talking about. over populating the country with immigrants is not going to fix the benefit culture, only make it worst as there really wont be any jobs left even for those that do want them.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Casimir on April 09, 2013, 05:16:07 pm
As stated the issue is with the benefit culture and the national work ethic (or more over lack of it) rather than immigration.  There are jobs out there, its a matter of whether people are willing to take them or not.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Lars on April 09, 2013, 06:41:24 pm
I don't know much about Thatcher(almost nothing),  probably because i was too young or i wasn't even born, however  the first things that come to my mind about her  are :  the Falklands "war" and the anti-hooliganism policies/laws during her government, that almost completely eliminated violence around football stadiums.
Yesterday at the radio they said that Margaret  Thatcher was  Britain's prime minister for 11 years, I didn't even know she ruled for such a long time.

Could  anyone tell me please if the movie they made about her( it should be called "the iron lady" or something like that) is any good? 




Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Leesin on April 09, 2013, 06:44:12 pm
As stated the issue is with the benefit culture and the national work ethic (or more over lack of it) rather than immigration.  There are jobs out there, its a matter of whether people are willing to take them or not.

Again you are talking about something I am not, I am talking about over population, not the laziness of people/people not geting jobs which has been an issue long before immigration. Over population means that those that do really want to work are going to struggle alot more in actually obtaining a job even for a shit wage. Things are getting better right now where work is concerned, but  in 10 years if the current population growth and immigration continues, then people really will be fighting to earn a living again.

 The other issue with having way too many migrant workers is that they are actively taking a lot of money out of the system, many of them send large sums of money back to their home countries in saving accounts or to their families, taking money out of our already shitty economy. Many of the immigrant workers I know all have quite a few people living in one home, the rent doesn't cost them much when it's split between them all and they don't mind living on the bare minimum to survive because the money they are saving will allow them to buy a house outright in their home countries. Which means that wages stay low even for the native Britishe struggling here who will never be able to afford to buy a home here, in their own country.

I'm all for migrant workers from the EU, I work alongside some of them and most of them are hard working, but there has to be a cap on how many can work here at a time, a migrant work force if limited will help us build our economy back up, but an unlimited flow of them pouring into the country will only damage it in the long run.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 10, 2013, 12:13:31 am
I dunno about any British numbers on immigration. Simpy don't...

...but I know about the German numbers.

The tricky part here is - and it's always forgotten, except by the real serious newspapers and articles - for those 100k coming in, there are always a lot of others leaving in the same timeframe.

I remember reading an article in the newspaper about it. Don't call me on the correctness of the numbers but the relation should be fine:

In 2010 100k immigrants came to Germany. In the same time 75k "people" left the country. So, overall the real growth is way smaller than the first number suggests.

Sure, this opens a lot of other issues. I am merely trying to point out that there is more to immigration than just the naked "incoming".
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Kafein on April 10, 2013, 03:56:17 am
Yeah, maybe thats true for some of the younger ones. But I don´t get it why lecturers and profs are mostly left-minded.

Lecturers and intellectuals in general tend to be more progressive, and generally choose whatever political group is not conservative. Hard sciences have more of a liberal background, human sciences are closer to socialism.

Btw Leesin, what is so bad about the EU ? You know there is no european institution you didn't vote for, right ? They only seem distant because local medias never ever speak about what the union does except when it is crap, or perceived as such. In fact, there's no reason to be any more angry against europe than against your own national government, you don't have much more influence over that one.

Also the problem about immigration isn't people coming to "steal jobs". They buy other things with their salary and stimulate the economy, especially considering the fact that poor immigrant workers are willing to take crap jobs, and we direly need the educated ones (physicians for example) that literally flee their homeland. The problem is a flow of extremely poor people that need government help so much they make huge gaps in your budget. "The New Colossus" isn't just words, immigration is basically what built the USA during the 19th and 20th centuries. A notable difference with now being the relative absence of any kind of welfare, and the ten times worse misery in which some of the unluckiest immigrants were living.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Tennenoth on April 10, 2013, 06:35:13 am
An impressive career, although i disagree with the policies she enacted and the course she led society down.  Economic revitalisation and the expense of thousands of peoples jobs, homes and communities.  Its no surprise there was a lot of resentment to thatcher, i also don't think breeding 'new labour' is anything to be proud of.

Hindsight is of course 20:20, but tearing up the railways, closing the mines and the heavy industry in the UK were terrible decisions all made under her leadership.

Not targeting this entire post but I was told the mines were running out anyway? I thought that was the reason she didn't give into their strikes, when the strikes went on, the miners turned violent. Again, as I mentioned beforehand, not my first hand account, that is what my Grandfather has said. I take no responsibility! :wink:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/datablog/2013/apr/08/britain-changed-margaret-thatcher-charts

That seems quite informative for graphs etc for certain things, I don't know how accurate it is because its a newspaper writing it but it visualises some things nicely. To be honest, I don't know if the Guardian is for or against Thatcher but that seemed to show good points and bad points although I can't see how the life expectancy comes into play since medical advancements are usually the major driving factor for that.

The major ones I would say are the economy stimulation, the unemployment rates & the decline in manufacturing. My favourite one however is the pay-gap between men and women, I would have expected it to have shot drastically towards equal for women, but it only started in the latter years of her office and continued.

One thing about this whole debate has spurred me to look at the class system that Britain has today. I've learnt a lot actually and I am starting to understand how it is such a problem for some people. I always understood that I was bloody lucky to be in the position that I am in today, my parents are well off, they're still together, I'm at University, I'm employed (multiple at once too) and generally speaking my life has been damned easy, everything has been given to me, I've not had to fight for anything but reading up on the "classifications of people" I have really started to see how much of a divide there is, what the characterisations are and hilariously how my accent effects peoples views of me.

"Stealing British jobs" is just not something that happens these days and for my person views on it, the majority of the people who use it as an excuse are those who would much rather sit on benefits. I can understand the people who are actively looking for a job, those who want to get onto the market but I also believe that they are just using it to vent their frustration of having someone else picked over them, regardless of their ethnicity. I'm more than happy to have someone beat me out of a position if they are better than me, if I were the employer, I would pick the better person too, I'd be pissed off/disheartened but I can't resent them for that, it just means I have to improve. If you want to come over here and work and you want to work hard, then by all means, you're welcome, but if you want to live off our frankly ridiculous benefits system, then bugger off.
I'm a strong believer that benefits should be a last resort. If you're injured and need support, then its there when you need it, if you are out of work then its there if you need it. It shouldn't be a "oh, its okay, I'll use the benefits" situation and it certainly shouldn't be a trap. What I mean by that is that it shouldn't be economically better for you to stay on benefits than to work so you don't bother.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: FRANK_THE_TANK on April 10, 2013, 08:05:22 am
I just wish she had died 9 days earlier so my uncle could have out lived the old bag!
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Overdriven on April 10, 2013, 08:23:52 am
Again you are talking about something I am not, I am talking about over population, not the laziness of people/people not geting jobs which has been an issue long before immigration. Over population means that those that do really want to work are going to struggle alot more in actually obtaining a job even for a shit wage. Things are getting better right now where work is concerned, but  in 10 years if the current population growth and immigration continues, then people really will be fighting to earn a living again.

 The other issue with having way too many migrant workers is that they are actively taking a lot of money out of the system, many of them send large sums of money back to their home countries in saving accounts or to their families, taking money out of our already shitty economy. Many of the immigrant workers I know all have quite a few people living in one home, the rent doesn't cost them much when it's split between them all and they don't mind living on the bare minimum to survive because the money they are saving will allow them to buy a house outright in their home countries. Which means that wages stay low even for the native Britishe struggling here who will never be able to afford to buy a home here, in their own country.

I'm all for migrant workers from the EU, I work alongside some of them and most of them are hard working, but there has to be a cap on how many can work here at a time, a migrant work force if limited will help us build our economy back up, but an unlimited flow of them pouring into the country will only damage it in the long run.

Yup I worked in a warehouse for 3 months with 80% Polish workers. The vast majority were planning to move back to Poland relatively soon. There was even one with a Philippine wife who was planning on buying a house out there. Most of them shared transport, housing, everything to save costs so they could move back to their own countries in a relatively short period and have earned a decent wage. I have nothing against them also as they were far more hard working than the majority of English people working in the same warehouse. I'd rather a way of forcing people on benefit back to work, even into crappy jobs, unless they have a very legitimate reason not to.

Fact is people complain about housing shortages/lack of money ect whilst typing on their fancy laptop, Ipad, Iphone, sitting infront of their big television with a house that is pretty much provided for them. Of course there are those with a legitimate struggle as well, but everything you hear about pre-Thatcher era related to state housing means outside toilet, no heating at all, working for a pittance and taking baths in front of the fire in a tin bath. I know this because my Dad lived in such accommodation. Fact is the every day standard of living for the vast majority of people is incredibly high compared to then.

Not targeting this entire post but I was told the mines were running out anyway? I thought that was the reason she didn't give into their strikes, when the strikes went on, the miners turned violent. Again, as I mentioned beforehand, not my first hand account, that is what my Grandfather has said. I take no responsibility! :wink:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/datablog/2013/apr/08/britain-changed-margaret-thatcher-charts

That seems quite informative for graphs etc for certain things, I don't know how accurate it is because its a newspaper writing it but it visualises some things nicely. To be honest, I don't know if the Guardian is for or against Thatcher but that seemed to show good points and bad points although I can't see how the life expectancy comes into play since medical advancements are usually the major driving factor for that.

The major ones I would say are the economy stimulation, the unemployment rates & the decline in manufacturing. My favourite one however is the pay-gap between men and women, I would have expected it to have shot drastically towards equal for women, but it only started in the latter years of her office and continued.

It was revealed afterwards that she offered Scargill the chance to see which mines were profitable and only close them afterwards if they aren't. Some mines definitely were profitable, but there were also a lot that weren't. Problem was that Scargill refused. Basically he was an utter twat and in all fairness the miners blame him just as much as Thatcher for what happened. He was to busy prattling on about socialism than actually caring for the welfare of those he was supposed to represent.

In terms of the equal pay for women, whilst Thatcher was a women, she notoriously hated feminists. So that doesn't really surprise me. Lots of feminists now would never pick her as a figurehead because they think her traits to manly (actually said this in some articles) which I find rather ironic.
Title: Re: Thatcher dead!
Post by: Molly on April 10, 2013, 08:25:36 am
I just wish she had died 9 days earlier so my uncle could have out lived the old bag!
My sincere condolences to you and your family.