cRPG

cRPG => Archive => Game Admin aBooze => Topic started by: Ganon on April 15, 2011, 02:02:02 pm

Title: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: Ganon on April 15, 2011, 02:02:02 pm

Why ? Because this forum section is full of threads with players being abused (17 threads in this section, 7 for lilith) by him and this made me change my mind about voting last time against the removal of his admin powers. I would like the chance to vote again. Personally i never had a problem with him but obviously something is wrong, i can understand one or two angry players but not half the admin abooze section being about him. To be clear, i'm not requesting the removal of his admin powers based on one particular incident, but on the overall picture of the last 1-2 months.

Edit: To clarify, since people say i need to state the reason of abuse. There's half a forum of reasons, i'm not quoting all the threads but you can read them, that's multiple reasons, and it got alot worse after the vote to remove him. Based on all those specific episodes, i think Lilith got overconfident after passing one admin removal vote, and started abusing his powers.

Title: Re: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: ChrystTheEmperor on April 15, 2011, 02:13:18 pm

+1

Title: Re: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: Electro on April 15, 2011, 02:14:27 pm

+1

Title: Re: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: polkafranzi on April 15, 2011, 02:54:14 pm

Please read the bolded bit in the spoiler:

(click to show/hide)

Quote from: chadz on February 24, 2011, 03:04:10 am

unless you read this post carefully. This is not supposed to be a joke forum, it's a troll free zone.

We've been thinking for some time how to make a fair compromise between players and admins.

We hereby present you the admin abuse Forum.

These are the rules, they are STRICT, you WILL get warned, muted or banned for ignoring them!

A. Nomination Phase
The Nomination Phase looks like this: you accuse an admin of abuse. You have to state the reason. Do this by posting a new thread with the name of the admin in the thread title. If me or cmp have the feeling that you are just joking around, there will be a mute incoming and your thread be deleted.

B. Nomination Phase, Part 2
Now you need people sharing your opinion on the abusing admin. You have to get 20 unique posters in here that share the dislike of the adminning action of above mentioned admin. They dont have to state a reason, it might help though. ONE POST ONLY, NO spam, NO chitter, also NO defending. Purely stating that you dislike admin actions. The only exception is the accused admin - he may post 1! post on his defense. No discussing of the topic. Also, if we get the feeling you are joking around, your post gets removed and you will get muted. If the required amount of posters is not reached in 5 days, the nomination fails.


C. Voting phase
When 20 posts are reached, a public, anonymous vote will be started, that will run for 72 hours. After that time, admin status will be removed if 51% or more voted on removing him.

Because this is a very delicate topic and new concept, I might change rules on the fly. I apologize for this dictatorship like behaviour, but it might be necessary.

--------------------------
2 extra rules:
You cannot nominate an admin until 48 hours after the incident.
After a failed nomination or a finished vote, the same admin cannot be nominated for another 30 days.

+1

Title: Re: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: Noctivagant on April 15, 2011, 03:06:52 pm

Quote from: Leiknir on April 15, 2011, 02:19:33 pm

You can't be serious. Did you even read the threads? Most of them are Mercs thinking they are above the rules, then getting pissed when someone enforces the rules.

I'm sorry but your comment is not objective at all. With the same mentality I can accuse all the admins being against Mercs.
Do I? no, Did Cmp vote against Vicious? yes is he a Merc? yes When you sent me a pm about Nuffen did I give both of you a mature response? yes

Here is the full member list :

(click to show/hide)

Leaders
Oberyn
Olwen
Noctivagant
Members
pTx
Replica
Tempest
Jacko
Yaron
cmpxchg8b
Burrick
M_Pully
Mustikki
Varyag Shpongled
Assas_Janis_Corp
Vicious666
Mokk
Gresin
Vargas
Phazh
Akincibegi
Mtemtko
Siiem
Storm
Jambi
Bjord
Xant
Lizard_Man
Blueberry_Muffin
\/\/ar
Koldborn
Tuonela
DaveUKR

Could you please point out the ones you think that they think they are above the rules.

Lets talk about Nuffen :

Is he a nice guy? yeah time to time, he is human after at all (I hope) Do I find some of his decisions hasty? yes have I told him that personally? yes. He doesn't bother me that much but he has to think twice before he is making a decision. Thats all I suggest to him.

Btw Leiknir, I gave you the complete list of Mercenaries. Anyone who are not mentioned in the list are not Merc, seems like wherever you look you see a Merc.

Have a good day.

Title: Re: Nomination Lilith/Nuffen
Post by: [ptx] on April 15, 2011, 03:18:07 pm

(click to show/hide)

Quote from: chadz on February 24, 2011, 03:04:10 am

These are the rules, they are STRICT, you WILL get warned, muted or banned for ignoring them!

A. Nomination Phase
The Nomination Phase looks like this: you accuse an admin of abuse. You have to state the reason. Do this by posting a new thread with the name of the admin in the thread title. If me or cmp have the feeling that you are just joking around, there will be a mute incoming and your thread be deleted.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login