cRPG

cRPG => General Discussion => Topic started by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:02:51 pm

Title: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:02:51 pm
As we've all witnessed, communication between community and game admins is not going quite well lately. I know many of you don't even care to say the least, but the point is that something has to change if we want to see the bright future for our loving mod.

Reading through numerous unban requsts here and on Taleworlds forum I've noticed that many players didn't even know the real reason for being banned. And while we can argue that some just act innocent and others were banned for good reasons regardless, this clearly shows that there is a complete lack of communication from admins' part before executing the harshest penalty on the players. Reading some of the arguments from admins here was also discouraging. As I can recall in one case recently questioning admin's decision for a kick with a stupid and childish response "U mad?" resulted in an instant ban. This is not a way to treat your community that helps keeping this mod running with donations.

Given these cicrumstances I think it is fair to assume that some admins don't truly understand responsibilities that come with privileges of being a game admin. This is a just a small part of what can be found in the link I ran into (link provided in the spoiler section).

Game Admins must:
    * be honest and a desire to apply the rules to all players evenly
    * have a good sense of the game
    * have good knowledge of the decalogue and how it is to be interpreted
    * possess the ability to weigh the facts of a given situation and to make a decision accordingly
    * be able to conduct themselves in a professional manner when communicating with players
    * no longer be active player on the server they admin


(click to show/hide)

What our admins need is a similar guidline that will help them enforce the rules in a mature and consistent manner. There will always be those that will try to harm the gameplay experience of others for one reason or the other so, your community relies on your adminstrative skills to prevent this from happening, but right now it seems you often do the opposite. If this doesn't motivate you enough at least do it for the love of this mod.
Thanks in advance.

Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Alex_C on January 24, 2011, 03:05:11 pm
BUT I LOVEZ ABOOZE!!!
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Everkistus on January 24, 2011, 03:07:05 pm
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: cmp on January 24, 2011, 03:08:17 pm
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Babelfish on January 24, 2011, 03:09:40 pm
Gonna quote chadz from the other thread, incase you have missed it..Also i think it fits this thread nicely.

Quote from: chadz
I'm not sure if you are kidding or not.

If you are not - how fucking spoiled are you? You really think that admins are supposed to just fly around and watch people? For real? They are not getting paid - they are given some extra priviledges because they are trusted members of the community. No one EVER thought about them as cRPG cops that do nothing else but look around for criminals. They are there so there is someone that can enforce stuff if people try to abuse the system, in whatever way. And as far as I am concerned, they are also free to just ignore being admin if they feel like it, because I can truly understand that it is a tiresome priviledge.

(Note: this is not about this topic, but in general, I have no idea what this thread is even about)
About admin abuse: no one is perfect, I have taken that into account. People can do wrong decisions, that happens, it is not good, but nothing that surprises me. It is a problem if it happens more frequently or more.. biased against someone in particular, but nothing like that has happened so far afaik.

To the point: if you feel like there is admin abuse, report it in the forum, as has been done, obviously. We will probably not check it out in detail, there is not enough time for that, but there might be consequences if something happens more than afew times.

In the future, there might be a more democratic approach - eventually the possibility to elect and unelect admins, because after all, they are supposed to represent the community.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:17:32 pm
Gonna quote chadz from the other thread, incase you have missed it..Also i think it fits this thread nicely.

Yeah I've missed that. I liked that funny part the most - "...they are trusted members of the community..." :)

Nvm me then, there is a cool link for any admin to check it out if he/she wishes so. Other than that...

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Phazey on January 24, 2011, 03:18:00 pm
I have banned ONE guy for repeated teamkilling (Morn). He knew what he was doing and he sure as hell understood why he was banned. Then he wrote a short essay promising not to misbehave again and i unbanned him.

Mr. "AssPunisher", who are you to lecture me on my adminning? There are rules, we enforce them. I do not find your post 'motivating', i find it arrogant and somewhat misguided.

It is very hard to do good adminning and still enjoy the game. I spend hours spectating, often franticly clicking to get to the right player, struggling with the huge and hard to use player list to find yet another idiot who is ruining the game by unreachable roofcamping, teamkilling or hiding. And then i kick him or her, only to see the same person rejoin moments later and continue like nothing has happened.

It's hard work. It's ungrateful work. People lie, distort what happened and generally try anything to make the admins look bad afther they've been banned.
We have to constantly monitor all the ban- and unban-requests. We have to constantly stay in contact with eachother. It's hard to keep enjoying the game like that.

All i see lately are snobish and sometimes whiney 'waah waah- the admins abooze'-type of posts. Never once a thank you or a 'well done'.

That said, i do think some of my collegue admins could work on keeping up the appearance of professionalism. But please remember, these are all volunteers.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:21:48 pm
I have banned ONE guy for repeated teamkilling (Morn). He knew what he was doing and he sure as hell understood why he was banned. Then he wrote a short essay promising not to misbehave again and i unbanned him.

Mr. "AssPunisher", who are you to lecture me on my adminning? There are rules, we enforce them. I do not find your post 'motivating', i find it arrogant and somewhat misguided.

It is very hard to do good adminning and still enjoy the game. I spend hours spectating, often franticly clicking to get to the right player, struggling with the huge and hard to use player list to find yet another idiot who is ruining the game by unreachable roofcamping, teamkilling or hiding. And then i kick him or her, only to see the same person rejoin moments later and continue like nothing has happened.

It's hard work. It's ungrateful work. People lie, distort what happened and generally try anything to make the admins look bad afther they've been banned.
We have to constantly monitor all the ban- and unban-requests. We have to constantly stay in contact with eachother. It's hard to keep enjoying the game like that.

All i see lately are snobish and sometimes whiney 'waah waah- the admins abooze'-type of posts. Never once a thank you or a 'well done'.

That said, i do think some of my collegue admins could work on keeping up the appearance of professionalism. But please remember, these are all volunteers.


Given these cicrumstances I think it is fair to assume that some admins don't truly understand responsibilities that come with privileges of being a game admin.

Game Admins must:
    * have good knowledge of the decalogue and how it is to be interpreted
    * be able to conduct themselves in a professional manner when communicating with players


The only person being arrogant here is you. Didn't read past that sentence.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Phazey on January 24, 2011, 03:24:08 pm
I'm not being arrogant. I'm giving you my honest reaction. No need to requote your own post, i read it.
What, you are just gonna respond by saying: "No, you are arrogant instead"? Is that what it has come to?

Do you get why your post rubs me the wrong way?
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: nuffen on January 24, 2011, 03:25:39 pm
My wordbook translates decalogue to the 10 commandment of the bible.. wtf?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decalogue
I was not wrong. Ok, notice my nick, Lilith. Then, think.. uhm, you want to force-convert me to a christian just to be an admin? AND Im not allowed to play on the server I admin? How am I gonna admin then, sit there spectrating people for hours without pay?
Just the thought of that makes me a:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:28:35 pm
I'm not being arrogant. I'm giving you my honest reaction. No need to requote your own post, i read it.
What, you are just gonna respond by saying: "No, you are arrogant instead"? Is that what it has come to?

Do you get why your post rubs me the wrong way?

If you read it again (or the qouted part at least) carefully you will notice it wasn't directed to you. No reason to get mad over it. Keep doing a good job, thats all. And of course, thanks for your efforts.

My wordbook translates decalogue to the 10 commandment of the bible.. wtf?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decalogue
I was not wrong. Ok, notice my nick, Lilith. Then, think.. uhm, you want to force-convert me to a christian just to be an admin? AND Im not allowed to play on the server I admin? How am I gonna admin then, sit there spectrating people for hours without pay?
Just the thought of that makes me a:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


I don't believe in God, and I don't think anyone will mind you playing while admin at the same time. It was a copy-pasted part from the link provided, as clearly stated in my OP.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Astinus on January 24, 2011, 03:30:26 pm
I agree with OP.

Hang them on the highest tree and then burn them
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Murmillus_Prime on January 24, 2011, 03:31:21 pm
I believe asspunisher and phaz both have good points, but turning this into an argument about arrogance isn't what the thread is about. Asspunisher has picked up on the fact some admins on more than one occasion act on their 'powers' irrationally, and unfairly kick/ban people, not through rule breaking but through petty arguing and not being able to agree on the same level. Everyone is human here, we all have opinions and many of us don't see eye to eye but that's not a reason to ban somone or to kick them is it?

I've not been an admin I won't pretend to know how frustraiting being one is, yet the fact administrating a server is hard job doesn't justify douchebaggery conducted by some admins who resort to using their admin powers to have the 'last say'.

Lastly, I'd like to thank, the admins who've conducted themselves fairly, and unbiased and have kept a cool head throughout any issues regarding critisizm of their abilities. Admins like you, are glue to the community and the servers wouldn't be the same without them.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: nuffen on January 24, 2011, 03:35:04 pm
I believe asspunisher and phaz both have good points, but turning this into an argument about arrogance isn't what the thread is about.
So I need to convert to christianity, start spectrating hours a day without playing to admin? Are you serious mr, or are you just unprecise?
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:37:00 pm
Lastly, I'd like to thank, the admins who've conducted themselves fairly, and unbiased and have kept a cool head throughout any issues regarding critisizm of their abilities. Admins like you, are glue to the community and the servers wouldn't be the same without them.

+1
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Murmillus_Prime on January 24, 2011, 03:38:00 pm
So I need to convert to christianity, start spectrating hours a day without playing to admin? Are you serious mr, or are you just unprecise?

Neither.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:38:46 pm
So I need to convert to christianity, start spectrating hours a day without playing to admin? Are you serious mr, or are you just unprecise?

I obviously missunderstood what decalogue means. Can we move on now please?
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: BD_Guard_Bane on January 24, 2011, 03:43:33 pm
(click to show/hide)

On a serious note, I think AssPunisher should be made a special admin, with no ban/remove ban powers, and no kicks etc, but only the ability/responsibility to sit all day in spectate mode and screenshot misbehaviour. To help this along, you can delete his character and make him a permanent level 1 peasant, so he can concentrate on spectating.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: nuffen on January 24, 2011, 03:46:56 pm
I obviously missunderstood what decalogue means. Can we move on now please?

Sure, Ill move on to the next whinerthread. :)
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:46:59 pm
(click to show/hide)

On a serious note, I think AssPunisher should be made a special admin, with no ban/remove ban powers, and no kicks etc, but only the ability/responsibility to sit all day in spectate mode and screenshot misbehaviour. To help this along, you can delete his character and make him a permanent level 1 peasant, so he can concentrate on spectating.

I don't know what came into me while opening this thread, our admins are great!

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Vance on January 24, 2011, 03:48:41 pm
(click to show/hide)

On a serious note, I think AssPunisher should be made a special admin, with no ban/remove ban powers, and no kicks etc, but only the ability/responsibility to sit all day in spectate mode and screenshot misbehaviour. To help this along, you can delete his character and make him a permanent level 1 peasant, so he can concentrate on spectating.

+1

I don't know what came into me while opening this thread, our admins are great!

(click to show/hide)

What do you mean?
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Meow on January 24, 2011, 03:50:42 pm
love how these threads get derailed in seconds :D
go play on eu4 if you don't agree with the admins doing?
i sure don't agree with all the bans and kicks without warning but then again i don't really care.
if people fail to read two lines of text when they join a server and naked leech they don't deserve a warning...
same for people who fail at common sense.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:50:58 pm
What do you mean?

Forum joke... back to being serious now.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Vance on January 24, 2011, 03:52:00 pm
Forum joke... back to being serious now.

And yet somehow I still can't take you seriously. Funny that.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Joker86 on January 24, 2011, 03:56:08 pm
I don't want to participate in this argument here, especially as I am biased towards Phazhey. From his style of playing the game I know he is far away from a subjective point of view, but has a great feeling for "the whole thing", so in this special case I would say he is far beyond any doubt!

Though I heard scary stories about other admins, so you can't say it in general.


I would suggest the following thing to minimize the problems of the community not understanding or accepting admin decisions:


First of all you have to set up a catalogue of offences, and to make it public. Don't just list them up, but explain them and determine where the boundaries begin and end.

Whenever an admin kicks or bans someone, he has to add in chat to which rule he is referring to. As I assume in most cases the admins act justifiedly (does this word exist?  :? ), you can prevent most of the unjustified admin abuse threads.

Only when it's not clear how to apply a rule on a certain situation (or the other way round) there COULD be room for discussions, but even then I would say the admin decides.


You should set up concrete rules for different situations. E.g. archers are only allowed to run away at the end of the round when the ratio of enemies doesn't exceed the archer's k/d-ratio. (0 deaths counts as one death) So an archer with 2:1 (or 2:0) is allowed to run away from two enemies, with a 9:3 he is allowed to run away from 3 and so on.

At the first moment such rules sounds stupid, and yes, of course they definitely can be unfair, but I think the advantage of such a rule (it's decided this way, it's clear, it's unmistakeable, and thus there is no room for discussions and rage topics on the forum), so you should set those up by all means!
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: Murmillus_Prime on January 24, 2011, 03:56:36 pm
I'd love to see anyone who describes debating the fairness of being banned and kicked for not breaking the rules of a server, get perma banned for an injustice and then come back here and just write off anything rational said in these threads as 'whine'. It's ok to judge when you're unable to be judged yourself, but put yourself in somone elses shoes for once and maybe you'll learn to hold back on the smart remarks and snide comments.
Title: Re: Concerning Game Admins
Post by: AssPunisher on January 24, 2011, 03:56:50 pm
And yet somehow I still can't take you seriously. Funny that.

Uuuh you got me there.  :rolleyes:

No reason to discuss this topic any further as it has been discussed too many times before. Idea is in the OP so admins take it or leave it. Locking thread now.