Tithe for the Guild bank discussion

[Fluffy_Muffin]

The current system for gold deposits in the guild bank is "donations". I reckon some of the bigger guilds have some kind of internal system for deposits already in place within this donation system. The problem with this is that 100+ people must click and type each and every day, when it adds up that is alot of unecesary time wasted.

What i propose is a system for automated gold collection.
Why? Now that we have a guild armoury it would be a nice way of colection gold for looms that everyone can use for said armoury.
I can think of 3 different systems:



2. Tithe - this is the system most people like

Each member sets the ammount he is willing to pay daily. For example Joe is a high end gear crutch and he cannot pay 100 gold per day, he sets his tithe to 50 gold and John is a archer/ninja/peasent whatever, he can afford to pay more money so he sets his daily tithe to 500 gold.

The benefits of this system are that everyone can choose exactly what is the ammount they want to pay and they can ajust it at any time. In case they want to pay nothing at all the tithe can be put to 0 gold.

This system is theoreticaly the same as the current one just automated in practice for conveniece.

(click to show/hide)

Previously suggested systems

1. Tax

The rank 9-10 member of the guild sets a tax for the members, everyone pays the same preset ammount. For example the leader sets a tax of 100 gold per day, lets say the guild has 100 members that is 10000 gold per day in the guild bank and im sure none of the members will feel the dent of 100 gold.

3. A combination of both

The rank 9-10 member of the guild sets a minimum tax of 50 gold that everyone can pay. Joe can pay this but John wants to contribute even more, he sets his individual daily tithe to 500 gold.

Discuss

[Tanken]

I like it. KUTTs, Upvote this so I can have your money.

Signed,
Your Jewish Leader.

[BashirKhan]

^ lawl

[LordBerenger]

I like it. KUTTs, Upvote this so I can have your money.

Signed,
Your Jewish Leader.

Shalom!

[Fluffy_Muffin]

Poll added

[Andswaru]

The idea is good, but what happens when i decide to go ninja peasent mode in order to save for that +1 item i just cant live without? Dont want to be paying my daily tax then.
Also this is depended upon people always been able to play, what happens to player C who wants to stay in his clan with his freinds but can only play 2hours a week and thus looses money like a fat person in a chocolate store.
So voted no, but thought id at least justify my reasoning to you. 

[Bryggan]

The idea is good, but what happens when i decide to go ninja peasent mode in order to save for that +1 item i just cant live without?

Not a problem if the guild is supplying loom pointed stuff in the armoury.

Percentage would make more sense, in case someone has to disappear for a week or two.

[Fluffy_Muffin]

The idea is good, but what happens when i decide to go ninja peasent mode in order to save for that +1 item i just cant live without? Dont want to be paying my daily tax then.
Also this is depended upon people always been able to play, what happens to player C who wants to stay in his clan with his freinds but can only play 2hours a week and thus looses money like a fat person in a chocolate store.
So voted no, but thought id at least justify my reasoning to you. 

Then you set your tithe to 0

If the 2nd system were implemeted

[Idzo]

Very good idea. +1

I was thinking about same.

Sine its complicated to transfer money all the time around.

Also.. Some have donated almost 200k some none.
This would be fair thing to do since clan has to buy banner and help poorer members.


Also, i would like to see 2nd system implemented.

[bosco]

Goddamn socialist 

[bagge]

No taxes! What about my money?

[Idzo]

Goddamn socialist 

Good idea! I'm gonna roleplay Robina in tha hood (gangsta version) 

[Leshma]

Bad idea. If someone wants to donate, he'll donate. Big clans already have more than enough money for purchasing banners.

[Miwiw]

I like the system and idea, therefore a +1. However everyone should decide to donate or not to donate. So everyone should be able to decide himself.

So I approve the second point.

[Fluffy_Muffin]

Op changed:

2. Tithe - this is the system most people like

Each member sets the ammount he is willing to pay daily. For example Joe is a high end gear crutch and he cannot pay 100 gold per day, he sets his tithe to 50 gold and John is a archer/ninja/peasent whatever, he can afford to pay more money so he sets his daily tithe to 500 gold.

The benefits of this system are that everyone can choose exactly what is the ammount they want to pay and they can ajust it at any time. In case they want to pay nothing at all the tithe can be put to 0 gold.

This system is theoreticaly the same as the current one just automated in practice for conveniece.

The idea is good, but what happens when i decide to go ninja peasent mode in order to save for that +1 item i just cant live without? Dont want to be paying my daily tax then.
Also this is depended upon people always been able to play, what happens to player C who wants to stay in his clan with his freinds but can only play 2hours a week and thus looses money like a fat person in a chocolate store.
So voted no, but thought id at least justify my reasoning to you. 

You can put tithe to 0.

No taxes! What about my money?

You can put tithe to 0.

Bad idea. If someone wants to donate, he'll donate. Big clans already have more than enough money for purchasing banners.

This system is theoreticaly the same as the current one just automated in practice for conveniece.

I like the system and idea, therefore a +1. However everyone should decide to donate or not to donate. So everyone should be able to decide himself.

So I approve the second point.

From the replies of the community decided that the tithe system is the most convenient, you can put any ammount you want